Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectTransgender women are not natural women no matter
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13330637&mesg_id=13456784
13456784, Transgender women are not natural women no matter
Posted by allStah, Mon Mar-28-22 07:38 PM
how much you want to spin or push that dogma. When arguing something as fact,
there must be evidence, proof, science, etc to prove or validate your point.
Your are basically dismissing biology for the sake to feel right, even though
you’re not.

You state that transwomen are women, then what is YOUR definition of a woman?

- Biological women ( not intersexed or some type of genetic defect) have XX
sex chromosomes

- Biological women have natural breast and can produce milk when in pregnancy

- Biological woman have ovaries and a uterus

Those are just a few natural properties that biological women possess.


Transgender women do not naturally possess those properties, and the muscle
mass, bone density, and testosterone that men generate don’t just magically
disappear because a man decides to change his gender to female. She/He is
still 100 percent biological male, and taking hormone inhibitors does no eradicate
the strength and power that the male body developed prior to transitioning into a TRANSGENDER woman. That is a huge advantage that transgender women
have over biological women.


Moreover, and this is the most ridiculous part of it all. In order for a transgender
woman to become eligible to compete in a NCAA women’s sport, the transgender
has to be on hormone inhibitors for at least one year PRIOR to seeking eligibility, and
must remain on inhibitors after becoming eligible.

So a transgender woman has to take a chemical in order to limit the amount of
testosterone that his/her body produces, because without that artificial action
a transgender woman wouldn’t be able to emasculate his body in order to
become eligible to compete.

Is this what we want to allow in sports, when sports are based off the natural performance and physical presentation of the human body?

A biological woman doesn’t take any artificial substances or chemicals in order to be
a woman. Her existence is organic and natural, so why should she be coerced to
compete against a transgender woman who has to ingest or inject a substance
in order to become eligible to compete as a woman ?

There needs to be a natural/biological division and a transgender division, similar
to bodybuilding, where there is a natural division that is separated from
the regular division of professional bodybuilding.

In the natural division of bodybuilding, body builders do not ingest or inject their
bodies with any hormones or inhibitors. Their nutrition and health practices
are 100 percent natural.

In the regular division, there are no rules against bodybuilders using PEDs
or steroids.

Women’s sports need to go in that direction to maintain the integrity and fairness
of women’s sport.

One women is biological. The other is transgender. THERE IS A HUGE
DIFFERENCE, and sports need to reflect that. They are not the same.