It just seems like Dr. West is mad at Coates for being something he isn't and apparently not interested in being, instead of actually critiquing his writings.

and questioning of his celebrity status seems like a shot to try and de-legitimize his voice.

I think the comparison to Malcolm X was not based on an extension of his worldview or ideology but rather a statement that he is an example of a strong black man.

The critics seem to ignore that Obama ran as a centrist and had to deal with an intransigent republican legislature. Obama is just more of a realist than an idealist. I think many had unrealistic expectations about what he could really accomplish as the first Black president.

but what i'm trying to understand is, what is the crux of this debate? Are the differing views really mutually exclusive? what is the difference any of it makes in our lives.


Still I think they are both brilliant, but this just seems like a distraction.