Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectIt leaked.
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13092637
13092637, It leaked.
Posted by atruhead, Thu Nov-10-16 09:25 AM
There wasn't even a okayplayer.com for us to discuss anything on when The Love Movement dropped

let's keep things clean
13092649, so how is it?
Posted by makaveli, Thu Nov-10-16 09:51 AM
13092702, it's on my computer, Im working on my laundry list of tasks
Posted by atruhead, Thu Nov-10-16 10:26 AM
I'll take a walk in a few hours and check it out
13092655, throw some D's on it.
Posted by FLUIDJ, Thu Nov-10-16 09:56 AM




































































diapers
13092659, How is it?
Posted by legsdiamond, Thu Nov-10-16 10:01 AM
There is a listening party in Charlotte tomorrow but I don't think I can make it.

How mad will I be if I can't make it to the listening party?
13092663, ^
Posted by Boogiedwn, Thu Nov-10-16 10:04 AM
not asking for a Lesson review - just how is it?
13092775, for folks that grew up on Tribe, I think this would be wild to hear in a group
Posted by Nodima, Thu Nov-10-16 11:25 AM
there is a lot to unpack.

I think you're going to see a large group of people that don't consider this a "Tribe" album, not because it's Q-Tip heavy or anything but just the sound of it.

~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." � Jay Bilas
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
13092995, From what I heard so far, it's definitely a strong album
Posted by legsdiamond, Thu Nov-10-16 02:32 PM
13092665, tomorrow morning at the gym is when I'll unveil it...
Posted by Dstl1, Thu Nov-10-16 10:04 AM
not spoiling it for myself. I don't een wanna hear a snippet.
13092666, God dammit I though yout were talking about Trump Apprentice tapes.
Posted by stravinskian, Thu Nov-10-16 10:05 AM

I'll force myself to wait a day to get the Tribe album as intended.
13092700, Call a plumber.
Posted by flipnile, Thu Nov-10-16 10:26 AM
13092764, listening now...
Posted by legsdiamond, Thu Nov-10-16 11:15 AM
I have other shit going on so I cant concentrate but it sounds good to me.

This nigga sampled Bennie and the Jets.

Phife spittin hard as fuck!!!
13092772, spoiler alert. I can hear you'all saying...'boy, you're a jerk' (c)Lupe
Posted by Dstl1, Thu Nov-10-16 11:21 AM
.
13092773, judging from the first 3 songs, there will be a LOT of ideas on this album
Posted by Nodima, Thu Nov-10-16 11:23 AM
it definitely isn't a throwback album, it's pretty current.

shows a pretty strong influence from the production styles of Rising Down and ...Shoot Your Cousin on the first two tracks.

it's two discs, not sure if that was in the promotional material, but totals just over an hour (curious to see if the discs have totally different feels).

unless it changes course dramatically, this is going to be their darkest album easily, as well as most dense.

the guitars on this album are clean as fuck.

"Kids..." is a back and forth between Andre and Tip Beastie Boys style except about politics and blackness.


~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." � Jay Bilas
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
13092824, Oddly perfectly timed politically.
Posted by BigReg, Thu Nov-10-16 12:03 PM
Also I think the track 2 answers the if they grew from the song that will not be named, lol.

Its also, on first listen, MUCH better then The Love Movement.
13093286, I heard it and thought: "There goes the neighborhood!"
Posted by Creole, Fri Nov-11-16 08:38 AM
RE: Oddly perfectly timed politically.
>Also I think the track 2 answers the if they grew from the
>song that will not be named, lol.

Somebody gonna have a frowny face.

https://gwendolynndedanaan.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/frownyface.png


>Its also, on first listen, MUCH better then The Love
>Movement.

Much better and I'm only 8 songs deep at the moment.
13093716, you might need to listen to it again
Posted by Garhart Poppwell, Sat Nov-12-16 05:11 AM
They're talking about the climate in America. "Muslims and gays/boy, we hate your ways"-why would Tip hate Muslims when he is one?
13093727, uhh, you might need to read his post again
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 06:54 AM
13093851, damn I fucked that one up
Posted by Garhart Poppwell, Sat Nov-12-16 09:32 PM
13092854, Set my alarm to wake up early tomorrow to download...
Posted by Creole, Thu Nov-10-16 12:27 PM
Wanna be sure to get to it before the servers crash.

Can't wait! (c) Bart Scott
13093157, very minimal complaints
Posted by atruhead, Thu Nov-10-16 05:31 PM
Im not a fan of Jarobi rapping but it's as good as an album we're going to get 18 years since the last one
13093178, It's cool so far. You def see the difference without a Dilla tho
Posted by Heinz, Thu Nov-10-16 06:49 PM
Like...Ionno how I can explain. But you can just tell what he brought to the production on certain joints. And thats def missing on here. I didnt find myself giving a fuck about most of the production nor really breaking my neck.

I feel like "Dis Generation" is the joint where i feel the same as I did when say Love Movement dropped

Gonna keep listening this week tho.

13093186, Dilla produced on their two least loved albums
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Thu Nov-10-16 07:19 PM
What is the new album missing that you feel BR&L and TLM had?
13093344, those last 2 albums were my least favorites.
Posted by tariqhu, Fri Nov-11-16 10:56 AM
they did pretty damn well without him on their first 3.
13093395, Lol @ Dilla bringing necksnapping to Tribe albums
Posted by Garhart Poppwell, Fri Nov-11-16 11:40 AM
Tribe needed a return to the self-made production style from their first 3 albums. Those Tribe albums benefitted Dilla more than they did Tribe. I love the guy too, but come on man.
13094066, Tribe lost the head snapping with Dilla
Posted by stattic, Mon Nov-14-16 08:16 AM

They were better off handling production in house
13093182, it feels restrained, yet it's not
Posted by willothewisp, Thu Nov-10-16 07:00 PM
they're rapping their asses off and it's funky, yet it's not

they know what works.

don't know if i'll be keeping coming back to it though... we'll see
13093205, listening now
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Thu Nov-10-16 08:36 PM
tip lost me with the chorus on we the people
13093210, solid wall of sound is dope
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Thu Nov-10-16 08:43 PM
as is the space program
13093244, The Space Program had me doing cartwheels down the street
Posted by atruhead, Fri Nov-11-16 12:33 AM
only about half of the album gave me the mean scrunch face, but they delivered nonetheless
13093828, same here
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Sat Nov-12-16 07:30 PM
13093211, dis generation *thumbs up*
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Thu Nov-10-16 08:47 PM
13093223, Yessir
Posted by legsdiamond, Thu Nov-10-16 09:32 PM
13093226, Yes!
Posted by SP1200, Thu Nov-10-16 09:47 PM
13093267, Hell yeah!
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Fri Nov-11-16 07:36 AM
13093215, kids is mehhhhhh
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Thu Nov-10-16 08:49 PM
13093264, Tough crowd. This is dope. Specially considering it should be awful.
Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Fri Nov-11-16 06:50 AM

**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
13093269, Why should this be awful?
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Fri Nov-11-16 07:36 AM
13093271, its hard to catch lightening in a bottle 20 years later?
Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Nov-11-16 07:57 AM
I would think that is his point.

Especially for rappers.
13093298, ^^^^
Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Fri Nov-11-16 09:21 AM

**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
13093368, How many musicians can go 17 years between albums and still be dope?
Posted by KosherSam, Fri Nov-11-16 11:19 AM
13093388, lol..yall know Nick understands the layoff and all...
Posted by Dstl1, Fri Nov-11-16 11:34 AM
but you have to admit that "should be awful" is way to strongly worded.
13093424, awful for Tribe is still decent hip hop
Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Nov-11-16 12:44 PM
I thought BR&L was awful and people on here loved it.
13093686, They're acting like Tip hasn't produced dope music post TLM
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Fri Nov-11-16 09:08 PM
13093309, Lost Somebody!
Posted by Creole, Fri Nov-11-16 09:47 AM
Got damn!

RIP Phife!
13093435, It's a great sound...it's truly a modernized Tribe album. The guitars,
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Fri Nov-11-16 01:05 PM
the drums, the melodies, the BPMs, the vibes...it's all so true to Tribe.

The DJ in me just wishes they had at least 3-4 TRUE standout songs...like how Amplified had (hell, Amplified had 6-8 standouts to me).
13093531, it's basically
Posted by The3rdOne, Fri Nov-11-16 02:39 PM
"Kamaal The Abstract" and "The Renaissance" Q-tip type production with all of them as a group on it.

And that's a great thing.

Maybe the reason why there was no lead single prior to dropping.
13093538, exactly this
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Fri Nov-11-16 02:52 PM
>"Kamaal The Abstract" and "The Renaissance" Q-tip type
>production with all of them as a group on it.
>
>And that's a great thing.
13093644, SHIT. I was actually talking about The renaissance when I said Amplified
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Fri Nov-11-16 05:21 PM
But hell, I actually feel the same about Amplified having 6-8 standouts...at least a good 4-5 on there
13093647, hell yeah...
Posted by Dstl1, Fri Nov-11-16 05:27 PM
Wait Up
Breathe and Stop
Higher
Let's Ride
Do It
Vivrant Thing
Things U Do
13093768, crazy to think how people say Dilla
Posted by The3rdOne, Sat Nov-12-16 10:54 AM
and Tribe's chemistry didn't hit. Well shit...Dilla and Tip CERTAINLY didn't suffer from that.
13094154, The chemistry definitely worked well with solo Tip. With Tribe...
Posted by SP1200, Mon Nov-14-16 11:56 AM
not so much. Not that it was wack, I don't think anyone can argue
that, but nobody does Tribe like Tip (production), nobody.
13094393, Dilla wasn't DILLA at all in 1996, either. On Love Movement, he showed
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Mon Nov-14-16 07:11 PM
maaaaajor flashes, and then Fantastic Vol 2 is basically a better, more polished version of Love Movement, production wise. Then, he just took all the way off.
13093520, This is really really good on first listen.
Posted by Ryan M, Fri Nov-11-16 02:32 PM
The Donald goes hard.
13093528, I like side 2 much better than side 1.. BLACK! SPASMODIC!
Posted by MeshaMeesh, Fri Nov-11-16 02:39 PM
THat's def my favorite track on the album. I really really connected more with side two, but I only listened once. I'm sure my feelings will change later on.

I like it.

I can't tell YET if/where it would fit in with the other albums. Heck. Is it even supposed to?

Overall I'm enjoying and I did get moments of "oh this def feels like how Tribe should feel in 2016"


"I'm twenty-two, catch
In the prime of my life,
I don't have time to be a wife"

https://twitter.com/MeeshUniVerSoul
https://instagram.com/soul.con.fusion/

"She was on that tip about stoppin' the violence
About my people she was teachin' me..."
13093542, jarobi channeled phife all through this
Posted by Ashy Achilles, Fri Nov-11-16 02:52 PM
13093548, for sure
Posted by MeshaMeesh, Fri Nov-11-16 03:03 PM

"I'm twenty-two, catch
In the prime of my life,
I don't have time to be a wife"

https://twitter.com/MeeshUniVerSoul
https://instagram.com/soul.con.fusion/

"She was on that tip about stoppin' the violence
About my people she was teachin' me..."
13093748, Jarobi tore the house down before KRS tossed PM Dawn off stage
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 09:13 AM
at that show way back in the day.

I used to see Jarobi in DC back when we threw shows at State of the Union on U street.

Always wondered why he left the group. He said he wanted to do other things (pretty sure he was a chef at the time) but I wondered if there was more to the story.

13093621, it leaked and it's great
Posted by rdhull, Fri Nov-11-16 04:36 PM
13093650, I still havent listened to the whole album
Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Nov-11-16 05:41 PM
Gonna spark one, put on the beat headphones and let it bang

I know people hate beats headphones but they were free
13093721, I heard some snippets and I thought someone was playing a joke on me.
Posted by denny, Sat Nov-12-16 05:44 AM
Perhaps I should reserve judgement but this does not sound like what I was hoping for.
13093726, That's because it isn't a real Tribe Album
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 06:52 AM
It's a compilation IMO.

It has its moments and the first half had me hype but the second half was a disappointment.

It's not bad... but it's not as great as I thought after hearing the first 6 or 7 cuts.

The production on the second half is ... terrible.

It's like Tips ego got in the way and he couldn't stop adding samples to songs that were already good.
13093735, The common album is a kabillion times better.
Posted by denny, Sat Nov-12-16 08:41 AM
Man....Common could win a grammy type good. That Stevie Wonder 'Black America again' is still on repeat for me.
13093742, That's because we are used to Obama carrying an album dolo
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 09:04 AM
Tribe has always been Tip and Phife... this album isn't Tight and Phife and honestly, I was never a fan of QTip as a solo artist.

Dis Generation is gorgeous and if more songs had that vibe I would be all in.

13093747, most of the time opinions are not definitive
Posted by atruhead, Sat Nov-12-16 09:12 AM
"I feel like" or "in my opinion" is a great way to preface statements many people would disagree with

it's perfectly fine that we have different feelings on things, but flat out telling the world "nah this new album shits on the one you're loving" is pretty sketchy
13093753, You really need a disclaimer that his opinion... is an opinion?
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 09:55 AM
13093920, Don't think the 2nd half is terrible, but I do prefer the first half too.
Posted by SP1200, Sun Nov-13-16 04:02 AM
13093683, after a second listen I like it even more
Posted by atruhead, Fri Nov-11-16 08:47 PM
it could end up in my top 10 albums of the year. Q-Tip is a genius
13093696, Second listen assessment: not sure why y'all ain't losing your mind
Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Fri Nov-11-16 11:04 PM
This shit is great.


**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
13093725, finally had a chance to sit with the album without any distractions
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 06:46 AM
First half of the album is good, almost great

Second half tho?? Le poo poo

I don't know wtf Tip was doing production wise on the second half of the album. There are 3 or 4 songs on the second half where a Tribe track is in there but he added 2 or 3 layers of trash that fucked up the songs. Those songs are fucking ruined IMO. This isn't really a Tribe album.

My early assessment was based on the first half of the album. Almost wish I never listened to the rest of it.

This is a 3 mic album.




13093733, I should admit I've only been listening to the first half of the album
Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Sat Nov-12-16 08:15 AM
I hear the first 5 songs loose my mind, then get distracted with life.



>First half of the album is good, almost great
>
>Second half tho?? Le poo poo
>
>I don't know wtf Tip was doing production wise on the second
>half of the album. There are 3 or 4 songs on the second half
>where a Tribe track is in there but he added 2 or 3 layers of
>trash that fucked up the songs. Those songs are fucking
>ruined IMO. This isn't really a Tribe album.
>
>My early assessment was based on the first half of the album.
>Almost wish I never listened to the rest of it.
>
>This is a 3 mic album.
>
>
>
>
>


**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
13093743, Same here.. I kept starting it over at work due to interruptions
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 09:07 AM
i will prolly edit the album down and rock with the 8 to 10 songs I like.
13093734, "Everyone else is wrong. All Opinions Matter!"
Posted by atruhead, Sat Nov-12-16 08:15 AM
.
13093745, wth is that supposed to mean?
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 09:08 AM
I
13093749, you're the odd man out, yet you somehow think your view is correct
Posted by atruhead, Sat Nov-12-16 09:15 AM
13093752, How did you come to this conclusion?
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-12-16 09:53 AM
No where in my post did I say everyone else was wrong.

13093758, it's all about language
Posted by atruhead, Sat Nov-12-16 10:05 AM
"I didnt like it" is perfectly acceptable
"maybe it's not for me" sounds even more rational

when everyone else says "this is great" and you say "this is trash", you're implying an absolute correctness on the issue

but I know you're not here to have discussions you can learn anything from, just to argue back and forth. I cringe when I see Talib Kweli doing that on Twitter, so I'll fall back and let you believe whatever you want
13093925, Nigga you are weird
Posted by legsdiamond, Sun Nov-13-16 08:17 AM
stop telling people how to give opinions

You have control issues fam.
13093949, actually Im a professional critic
Posted by atruhead, Sun Nov-13-16 11:11 AM
i'll never share much of that side of my life on here

but yeah keep on loudly fighting to be incorrect
13093962, #actually I'm not a professional critic.... so nigga please stfu
Posted by legsdiamond, Sun Nov-13-16 11:51 AM


13093967, we're having a discussion about critiques in a post I made though
Posted by atruhead, Sun Nov-13-16 12:18 PM
"nigga stfu, I think what I think because nigga stfu I think what I think" is the wrong way to go about these things

enjoy though
13094024, nah... we are critiquing the album
Posted by legsdiamond, Sun Nov-13-16 08:38 PM
stop trying to play editor at a magazine and let people give opinions based on their taste.

13094063, my mistake for forgetting where I made this post
Posted by atruhead, Mon Nov-14-16 07:42 AM
I cant tell the peanut gallery shit, no one is ever wrong here

you got it, the album is trash because that's your opinion
13094068, That's not even what l said tho... lol
Posted by legsdiamond, Mon Nov-14-16 08:37 AM
Why are you pouting like a kid because EYE said I thought the first half was great and the second half was booty?

I didn't say anyone else's opinion was wrong

Please stop acting like a bitch cause I don't like half the album.
13094102, you got it. thanks for being negative time and time again
Posted by atruhead, Mon Nov-14-16 10:28 AM
13094107, What's so negative about liking some of the album
Posted by legsdiamond, Mon Nov-14-16 10:33 AM
and not liking some of it?

Does everyone have to love it or they are being negative?

So silly...
13094124, your replies that aren't about the album are negative
Posted by atruhead, Mon Nov-14-16 11:06 AM
but it's fine, you'll never see who you are
13093825, DJ Quik did this a lot from Trauma onward too
Posted by Nodima, Sat Nov-12-16 06:51 PM
just doing things cause he's talented enough to make them work just enough to not be entirely whack, but they're still pretty whack.



~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." � Jay Bilas
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
13093984, would an example of this be...
Posted by Dstl1, Sun Nov-13-16 02:24 PM
whatever the fuck he was doing with the drum machine during Jarobi's verse on "Lost Somebody"? Shit actually snapped me out of the vibe of the song. I laughed out loud like..."fuck is you doing, Tip?" Overall, I respectfully disagree with you on the second half of the album. I think it's dope, but that one instance really jumped out at me. I know you have an artist's ear, though.
13094398, Yea those drums get stuuuuuuupid after the 2nd verse. Too
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Mon Nov-14-16 07:30 PM
experimental
13094418, lol...it didn't even make any sense, man...
Posted by Dstl1, Mon Nov-14-16 08:28 PM
I thought my headphones were dumbing out for a second.
13093829, What's cool is that is sounds like a "Tribe" album
Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Sat Nov-12-16 07:31 PM
You hear Space Program and it feels so familiar and almost like you heard it on another Tribe Album.

And yet it doesn't sound dated.

I was wondering what a tribe album would sound like in 2016 and it's exactly what I expected.

I mean this as a compliment though it doesn't quite sound like it.

**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
13093979, Well said
Posted by Mgmt, Sun Nov-13-16 01:42 PM
13093855, Jarobi is the MVP of this album...
Posted by rorschach, Sat Nov-12-16 09:55 PM
13093905, How is that possible when he's only on 5 songs?
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Sun Nov-13-16 12:57 AM
I dug the hell out of his performance but Tip is the MVP. I was right when I said this was a Tip album and he let his fam get on it. The album credits solidified it.
13093919, Because Jarobi comes through and crushes buildings....
Posted by rorschach, Sun Nov-13-16 03:43 AM
Tip does too but I really like Jarobi's verses here. I'm not as used to hearing Jarobi all over shit so that probably has something to do with it.

Phife's verses were strong too....there's just not enough of them unfortunately. I wonder how different this album would be if Phife hadn't died and could've saw this project through to the end.
---------------------------------------


---------------------------------------
13093946, I love it.
Posted by bwood, Sun Nov-13-16 10:55 AM
Better than Beats, Rhymes and Life. Better than The Love Movement.

"Solid Wall of Sound" was beautiful.

They kilt it on SNL last night too.
13093976, RE: It leaked.
Posted by Tiggerific, Sun Nov-13-16 01:25 PM
Yes, yes...Y-E-S!!!!!!!!!!!!!

As a 38 year old Black woman who LOVES A Tribe Called Quest, we needed this in our lives!!!!!

Thank you, Tribe!!!!!!!! I love the album(s).

Between Tribe, Common and Solange & Beyonce...with a little bit of last year Kendrick and Anderson Paak thrown in Unapologetically Black Music has been good. Now, if Kendrick Lamar dropped a surprised album to end this year it would seriously be the blackest Blackety black year in music. ✊🏿

13093987, Dis Generation damn near made me cry in public...
Posted by Dstl1, Sun Nov-13-16 02:29 PM
listened to the album for the first time this morning. 30 degrees out...I hit the street all Northfaced up and walked to the coffee spot. A shade over 2 miles each way. Nice, brisk walk with Tribe in the Bose cans. Thoughts after 1 complete listen:

Space Program is good...real good

Phife has some dope lines in We the People

Solid Wall of Sound might be my second favorite

I don't hate Kids...I feel like I should like it more than I do, though. Just a little wacky...I can't call it.

I don't usually care for rapper sex songs, but they made Enough work. It works. I like it.

They should have taken that 1st verse off of Mobius. The way Busta dismantled that track just wasn't fair...to anyone else.

Lost Somebody was tough

Conrad Tokyo made me smile ear to ear
13093988, the donald is my shit.
Posted by Bblock, Sun Nov-13-16 02:46 PM
13094001, Melatonin is A Million Times from Kamaal The Abstract LP
Posted by LeroyBumpkin, Sun Nov-13-16 04:26 PM
That's why I dig that song so much.
And again, that's why I think a lot of these tracks were from The Last Zulu.
13094036, I needed this...
Posted by Trinity444, Sun Nov-13-16 10:14 PM
We the people needed this...
13094073, Kinda nuts how the album is so 'post-trump'
Posted by BigReg, Mon Nov-14-16 08:46 AM
Gotta figure it weighed on all their minds how well he was doing. considering all the references towards his rise are sprinked all over here.
13094357, RE: Kinda nuts how the album is so 'post-trump'
Posted by bwood, Mon Nov-14-16 05:43 PM
Yup. Focusing on the lyrics now it's mos def political as fuck in a good way, not like in a bad way like Dead Prez's last album.
13094891, Not the poster's fault, but mods we need a better post title if this is
Posted by SP1200, Tue Nov-15-16 08:00 PM
the official Tribe post. Just so ppl know it's here.
13094909, Nah I was trying to avoid a certain coon's trolling
Posted by atruhead, Tue Nov-15-16 10:31 PM
13094916, oh damb.
Posted by SP1200, Tue Nov-15-16 11:50 PM
13094943, Trump winning has him in hiding
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Nov-16-16 08:38 AM
he won't be back for a minute.

13094899, musically toothless and staid | great lyrics
Posted by bearfield, Tue Nov-15-16 09:20 PM
the raps are topical, personal, introspective, and worldly. good stuff. there's definitely something to be said for aged rappers with an experience-informed worldview who can compose compelling verses. there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of that lately. i'm enjoying that aspect of the project

but i think i don't like the album. i find myself having pulled a 180 and i'm listening for the lyrics in spite of the music instead of the inverse. i'm not feeling any of these beats and that's probably going to put this album in the "one time listen" category. it's very apparent tip & co. haven't been making music for a long time. i don't know exactly what is happening with the drum programming at the end of "lost somebody" but it sounds amateurish. the beats sound stale and the mixing is bad. it sounds like someone trying to imitate tribe circa 2006 on cheap equipment instead of a collection of hip hop legends finding their inspiration again
13094910, have you kept up with what Q-Tip has done since like 2002?
Posted by atruhead, Tue Nov-15-16 10:33 PM
it's a continuation of that, he pretty much did the whole album
13094913, i haven't
Posted by bearfield, Tue Nov-15-16 10:55 PM
never mind. checked his discogs page and he's been working steadily since 02 but doesn't have much output. maybe a few tracks/year. it guess it just sounds like they haven't made music in a long time
13094940, check out Kamal The Abstract and The Renaissance
Posted by atruhead, Wed Nov-16-16 08:26 AM
they dont sound like Tribe, they sound like the evolution of Q-Tip. He's the producer of everything, so We Got It From Here follows that path

assuming you enjoy those, this album might make a lot more sense to you
13094917, For the love of god.
Posted by denny, Wed Nov-16-16 12:15 AM
Qtip made the whole TCQ discography except for TLM and BRandL. The first three albums were all Qtip productions. Making this record no different from those. He just never insisted on getting the credit for it.

Apologies...but this truth seems to allude so many. Qtip has stated in interviews....'i made all the beats for a tribe called quest'.
13094941, Im aware he and Ali did the bulk
Posted by atruhead, Wed Nov-16-16 08:33 AM
I was just explaining why this doesnt sound like "Tribe", Tip's sound has expanded beyond traditional hip-hop
13095281, Nope.
Posted by denny, Wed Nov-16-16 07:48 PM
My impression (contrary to what I always believed) is that Ali did the cuts and nothing else. Literally....EVERYTHING other than the dj flourishes and cuts was done by Qtip. The fact that he didn't get credit for that was a major sticking point in their relationships. I imagine that's why the liner notes are so clear this time around.

What I'm saying is that the fact Tip did the majority of the production is not different from the past. If anything....Tip did LESS on this album because of the various studio musicians and guest instrumentalists that were used. The first three albums were much more self-contained, Qtip 'solo' productions.

There are 2 beats on the first three albums that were not made by Qtip and those were made by Skeff Anslem (8 million stories and Show Business) Everything else was Qtip by himself. The only reason I'm clarifying this is because it shocked me when I found out around 6 years ago or so. I thought Muhammed was much more involved than he was.
13096331, Maybe you have different information from me
Posted by obsidianchrysalis, Fri Nov-18-16 08:31 PM
But while Tip likely did most of the legwork, Tip, Phife, and other producers were in the mix as well, adding ideas and suggestions to the music.

It wasn't just ALL Tip, much like Radiohead isn't ALL Thom.

The reason I say this, is that Ali was a talented producer in his own right and his skills and tastes likely pushed those productions into the "Tribe" sound that we all like.

That "sound" isn't as prevalent on this album because Ali wasn't involved very much with this album because he had other commitments.

13096433, Read the Qtip interviews in the aftermath of the breakup.
Posted by denny, Sat Nov-19-16 03:10 PM
Radiohead is a very bad analogy. They were WAY more democratic in contributions from other group members. The first three Tribe albums were essentially one-man production works. Others might have suggested some arrangement details....but put simply, Qtip made 99% of the beats by himself. I was surprised to learn this too.
13094945, QTip did a Kanye
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Nov-16-16 09:05 AM
or as Jay would say "if you want my old shit, buy my old albums"

I don't think Tip wants to do that old sound. Maybe it's dated to him or he feels he is better as a producer. I'm not feeling some of the production AT ALL but Dis Generation, Mobius, Spasmastic... are flames

Tip also tries to sing on some of these joints and I don't know why.

13095286, When you have access to a really good studio....
Posted by denny, Wed Nov-16-16 08:25 PM
it's probably frustrating to limit yourself with the inherent audio problems that sampling presents. To be honest...I'd rather listen to a Qtip 'bedroom production' than Tip with studio musicians in a studio. But that's me.
13095491, Yup... I remember in the documentary he showed how he made a beat
Posted by legsdiamond, Thu Nov-17-16 01:50 PM
For one of the classic Tribe cuts and it was lovely...

I think all those knobs in the big studios seduce producers into trying new shit.

but I don't like it as much as his old shit.

13094972, There is no 'Tribe sound' anyways. They evolved with each album
Posted by stattic, Wed Nov-16-16 09:55 AM

and as said above, this album is an extension of Kamaal the Abstract and the Renaissance. I still hear a Tribe album and think that it's great.
13094980, Nah... I think there is a Tribe sound
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Nov-16-16 10:10 AM
and there is also a QTip sound and after he did his solo shit I think he moved away from that sound and some people like it and some don't.

I think when there is a group and one of the guys goes solo or the group breaks up and reunites the sound won't be the same if the group isn't the same.

I think age and outside influences change so the sound changes.

Ionno, I still bump it and it's not a bad album overall but i think the track Kids is a prime example of what I don't like about the album and it's funny that 3stacks is on that track.
I get the feeling that Tip is like Andre and Phife is like Big Boi. One experiments and the other rhymes over the safe hip hop beats that most old fans love.

Crazy how Phife and Big Boi wanted to do shows and get that money a few times a year and Tip and 3 Stacks are like nah... I'm good. They want to act, sing and do other shit.



13095089, yeah, I don't hate Kids...but I could easily do without it
Posted by Dstl1, Wed Nov-16-16 12:41 PM
.
13095097, typical 3stacks
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Nov-16-16 12:45 PM
not a real song.. more like an idea
13095124, If 50% of your discography strays from your 'sound,' what is it exactly
Posted by stattic, Wed Nov-16-16 01:08 PM

Because people have been claiming Tribe strayed from its sound ever since BRL. I think that they have an approach to their art, but not a sound that one can adequately articulate.
13095287, More than 50% of Robert Plant's discography isn't Led Zeppelin.
Posted by denny, Wed Nov-16-16 08:30 PM
But he will always be mostly defined by what he did with Led Zeppelin. Same thing with Qtip. The sound he made with the first 3 Tribe albums will go down as the defining contribution of his artistry.
13096594, I know what sound defines them. I was talking about having a 'sound'
Posted by stattic, Mon Nov-21-16 08:32 AM

and meant it in response to the comment above about circa 2006 Tribe, which interesting enough, didn't exist. Tribe is defined by a sound but no one can reasonably expect them to deliver that sound in 2016.
13096371, The offbeat drumming is obviously done on purpose
Posted by Zarathuckya, Sat Nov-19-16 04:47 AM
So the question is why?

I would guess that it's to symbolise everything going to shit when a person you love is dying... and the abrupt cut off at the end is symbolic of how it can be to 'lose somebody' before their time.. Then the track goes quiet for like the next 30 seconds, which is symbolic of never hearing that persons voice again. I thought it was obvious given the topic of the song. Pretty sure I'm not over thinking it
13095098, Jarobi surprised me
Posted by AFRICAN, Wed Nov-16-16 12:46 PM
Didn't think he had it in him.
Busta blacked out on Mobius.
It had a few let downs but a great album.
Rip Phife.
Grew up on Tribe so this was a satisfying ending for me.
13095298, Jarobi got busy - would love to hear more
Posted by Roadblock, Wed Nov-16-16 09:17 PM
13096452, he has albums with him and Dres as a group
Posted by Garhart Poppwell, Sat Nov-19-16 09:49 PM
they're excellent, especially lyrically.
13096256, Conrad Tokyo tho...yeah.
Posted by Somnus, Fri Nov-18-16 04:48 PM
13096268, and where the hell is that sample from? I'm racking mybrain tryna figure
Posted by Somnus, Fri Nov-18-16 05:09 PM
it out.

I know it's a Stevie song but can't remember which one.
13096270, Nevermind.. got it
Posted by Somnus, Fri Nov-18-16 05:12 PM
13096276, https://youtu.be/OSgkBF6LjH4?t=4
Posted by Dstl1, Fri Nov-18-16 05:17 PM
https://youtu.be/OSgkBF6LjH4?t=4
13096281, iont know whatchu you listening to, bruh but my ears heard the opening
Posted by Somnus, Fri Nov-18-16 05:26 PM
of "Send One Your Love"...I mean, I could be way off tho
13096290, lol...no, you left us hanging...
Posted by Dstl1, Fri Nov-18-16 05:43 PM
so I just cued up that Pac song to where dude yells "Share it with me!!!', lol
13096297, Both of us were wrong...it's "Overjoyed".
Posted by Somnus, Fri Nov-18-16 05:59 PM
*edit*

and I didnt get that from an internet search.
13096301, Fuck, fuck, fuck....it is
Posted by Dstl1, Fri Nov-18-16 06:09 PM
.
13096274, LOL...YOOOOO!!! anyone ever catch this?
Posted by Dstl1, Fri Nov-18-16 05:15 PM
I just stumbled upon it. First 4 seconds:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wgklom8t8Y
13096355, i feel like this is the only place i can express my thoughts on this
Posted by esb225, Sat Nov-19-16 12:19 AM
let me first say great album i love it.
been bumping it non stop since last saturday...

now with that said it doesn't feel like a tribe album
there is no first verse with phife coming with heat...
his verses are good don't get me wrong but think of vintage tribe and you will get my meaning...
it feels very much like a Tip album where phife is on some tracks... now this isn't a bad thing and I understand how the album was made so it's understandable...

i blame myself for comparing them to their old selves and see they have matured... but again it's a great album.
13096387, I'm gonna make some people mad but fuck it
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-19-16 09:33 AM
I really like the album, there are 5 or 6 tracks I don't feel at all but the tracks I like, I really like.

All that being said, ever since the Tribe Doc I kinda soured on Tip. Maybe the documentary was slanted but it really felt like Tip didn't respect Phife.

Which brings me to the really shitty opinion about this album. Why the fuck is it coming out now? All these years Phife has said he wanted to tour, do a few shows, stack some cash and Tip wasn't having it. Now that Phife is gone it's videos and shows and shit.

My opinions ain't shit, I don't know what was really going on between them but dammit, something about this whole album doesn't sit right with me even tho I really like it. I know groups break up, get angry, vow to never perform again but the timing of this album is bittersweet for me.

Now I know of don't know what you got til it's gone... but man, this is really a Tip album with a few Phife appearances. Jarobi said this album killed Phife. What does that mean? The joy? The traveling?

Ionno... none of this is going to stop me from liking the music but every now and then when I see a performance or a video for the new material I wonder how Phife and his family feel about it. Maybe his health was so bad he couldn't tour.

All I know is this isn't a "Tribe" album IMO.

13096425, I actually feel like this album would have come out even if
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Sat Nov-19-16 01:59 PM
Phife was alive. It was an exact year ago when I was in NYC, and saw that they finally started performing together. I'm still mad I didn't go to their show that night. And it makes sense if this reunion actually lead to Phife's death in some way.
13096426, RE: I actually feel like this album would have come out even if
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Sat Nov-19-16 02:00 PM
>Phife was alive. It was an exact year ago when I was in NYC,
>and saw that they finally started performing together. I'm
>still mad I didn't go to their show that night. And it makes
>sense if this reunion actually lead to Phife's death in some
>way.
13096432, My read:
Posted by denny, Sat Nov-19-16 02:45 PM
Tip is the Paul Mccartney of Tribe. The unappreciated one that responds in a way that makes him look vindicative. He kinda feel into that trap of being too humble while it was happening and then having to over-correct later on and coming off self-absorbed. My guess is that in later years he became more concerned about his legacy (understandable) and probably really regretted not seeking out credit for his contribution while it was happening.

The others kinda resent him because he held all the power. He has more money than the others and didn't really need to do reunion tours....Whereas the others were probably a little desperate for that cash-in money. So you could see why they would resent the hell outta him. They kinda NEED him and he doesn't need them. That's a bad dynamic for friendship/group dynamics.

From Tip's perspective....he spread around credit for Tribe's sound in a pretty altruistic way. And you can see how many people underestimate his contribution...people have a really hard time accepting that he basically created their entire sound. This HAS to be frustrating for Tip. And the other members hesitancy in giving him that credit probably came off as a sort of betrayal in response to his generosity in never claiming it during those years. Then....when he tries to reclaim that credit in subsequent years he's characterized as being selfish. So you can see how it's frustrating for him too. Basically, the other guys were just along for a ride that he built...so you can imagine how it must feel when they make diss tracks about you and do interviews claiming that your the cause of the break-up. On some 'There'd be nothing TO break-up if it wasn't for me'. So he almost HAS to become the self-absorbed, unlikeable one even though this whole thing was HIS creation. (ala Macca)

I'd imagine Phife's wife and family are probably like 'we would've been alot more comfortable if Tip just cooperated' but Tip's counter would be 'I'm not responsible to carry everyone else's weight. If you really need me that badly then maybe you shouldn't make me look bad in the press'. It's just a lose-lose scenario....their tension isn't a lack of character...it's a pretty typical situation where everyone tends to double-down on their own perspective.

I'm just happy they had their Spinal Tap moment and found some common ground before it was too late.
13096438, I could definitely see everyone being justified in their arguments
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-19-16 04:10 PM
IMO Tribe was always QTip and everyone else. Phife was terrible early on but his voice was unique.

Thing is... way back when they first started I don't think most people cared, especially Tip. Probably wasn't until Pete Rock, Premiere and other producers started getting credit and Tip saw those publishing checks come in that he did the math.

Rap groups are funny, especially when one person does the heavy lifting on the humble.

I can see why Tip would be frustrated over the credit but that's the funny thing about groups. Fans like who they like and more times than not we just want the music and live shows.

Great points tho...
13096459, Yeah...
Posted by denny, Sat Nov-19-16 11:05 PM
I've read interviews with Tip where he says that producers were typically seen as crews instead of individuals. He specifically pointed to the Trackmasters and how he wanted to be part of a crew like that which made him less insistent on getting credit. And look at all the other acts leading up to Tribe....there are all sorts of unclaimed or unclear producer credit situations. I just always assumed the dj's made the beats during those years....so Eric B made Rakim's beats, Ali made Tribe beats, etc. Obviously I was very wrong but noone really seemed to care to make that shit clear back then. And you're right...the emergence of Pete Rock, Primo, et al becoming stars just for production work probably changed all that.
13099786, not only stars but frfr cultural ICONS. i haven't been up on much
Posted by poetx, Wed Nov-30-16 12:36 AM
of this so i never got into the details b/c in a naive kinda way i didn't want the ugly truths of the industry and all the 4080ish shit fuck up my recollections of tribe's Youthful Expressions.

i got the weebay face now w/ the realization that tip was doing most of the heavy lifting on the sound as opposed to ali shaheed. and then when it became about the ummah, and incorporating dilla alongside tip and ali, even then it seemed like the music got more artsy, but there were critiques of it being less tribeish.

i was legit mad at BR&L and thought, in total, it didn't hold up to the rest of the canon, but i fucks w/ The Love Movement just because some of the music was just so beautiful. (title track and 4 moms being just timeless, incredible joints to me). but the whole still didn't feel as atcq as i'd have liked.

>I've read interviews with Tip where he says that producers
>were typically seen as crews instead of individuals. He
>specifically pointed to the Trackmasters and how he wanted to
>be part of a crew like that which made him less insistent on
>getting credit. And look at all the other acts leading up to
>Tribe....there are all sorts of unclaimed or unclear producer
>credit situations. I just always assumed the dj's made the
>beats during those years....so Eric B made Rakim's beats, Ali
>made Tribe beats, etc. Obviously I was very wrong but noone
>really seemed to care to make that shit clear back then. And
>you're right...the emergence of Pete Rock, Primo, et al
>becoming stars just for production work probably changed all
>that.

this fucks w/ me on par with when i found out that eric b really ain't do shit.


peace & blessings,

x.

www.twitter.com/poetx

=========================================
I'm an advocate for working smarter, not harder. If you just
focus on working hard you end up making someone else rich and
not having much to show for it. (c) mad
13096508, #1 in the country
Posted by justin_scott, Sun Nov-20-16 03:34 PM
120,000 sold.
13096537, That's great....
Posted by rorschach, Sun Nov-20-16 06:35 PM
I'm glad the response was so big.....still wish Phife got the reap this reward personally....especially since he was the one who wanted to tour earlier on.


SN: Is there any way to see play counts on Spotify? I know I had this album on repeat all weekend.
13096587, Would the reception be the same if Clinton won?
Posted by Seven, Mon Nov-21-16 08:01 AM
13096588, ?
Posted by Dstl1, Mon Nov-21-16 08:08 AM
.
13096591, BigReg said it up top...and I've seen a couple articles
Posted by Seven, Mon Nov-21-16 08:18 AM
Floating around labeling it a 'post trump' album...I haven't read them to be honest.

I just think the album feels very timely given the state of things in America right now..I'm wondering if part of the reason it's doing so well (apart from it being a really solid album) is that people feel that timing as well....and if clinton won...would it be less relatable and not do as well? A good friend of mine thinks so


*edit. The question should've been a reply to the its #1 in the country post
13096592, it sounds like a rebuttal to Trumps victory
Posted by legsdiamond, Mon Nov-21-16 08:22 AM
it would still be a good album tho cause 'Murica!!!!

it's bigger than Trump.
13096609, Word
Posted by Seven, Mon Nov-21-16 09:34 AM
13096678, yes
Posted by atruhead, Mon Nov-21-16 11:19 AM
Stevie Wonder's "You Haven't Done Nothing" is political and still classic because it's good music (not calling the Tribe album classic)

some of the album deals with the threat of Trump winning. YG aside commercial Hip Hop hasnt really addressed it, but ATCQ may have looked even more heroic if the album dropped right after he lost
13099890, Word. I hear that.
Posted by Seven, Wed Nov-30-16 10:24 AM
13099109, Kids kinda kills the vibe of the album, but otherwise, amazing
Posted by justin_scott, Mon Nov-28-16 09:50 PM
and even Kids is a dope song, it just doesn't fit the vibe of the album.
13099406, It sounds like a 3 Stacks beat too
Posted by legsdiamond, Tue Nov-29-16 12:12 PM
Whole sound reminds me of a selfish nigga who would only be on the album if he got total control over the song.

That shit is trash.
13100212, I think it sounds more like a Big Boi track.
Posted by squeeg, Wed Nov-30-16 03:59 PM
I could definitely imagine him on it.