Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectWhat's harder to escape?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=12718087
12718087, What's harder to escape?
Posted by John Forte, Wed Dec-31-69 07:00 PM

Poll question: What's harder to escape?

Poll result (22 votes)
Poverty (18 votes)Vote
Obesity (2 votes)Vote
Addiction (2 votes)Vote

  

12718089, I voted obesity as it utilizes addiction. Then again.
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 10:45 AM
Poverty utilizes addiction too, hmmm, however, obesity is always easy to support. Plenty of cheap junk food. Addiction becomes harder and harder.
12718091, Poverty has the most external factors
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 10:47 AM
but obesity has the most enablers
12718093, poverty is generational
Posted by tariqhu, Wed Feb-04-15 10:47 AM
12718094, poverty.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 10:48 AM
b/c it often involves beating systems and institutions.

beating obesity and addiction are much more personal. pulling on one's own bootstraps and all that jazz.
12718095, I agree, yet somehow
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 10:49 AM
poor-shaming is far more socially acceptable than fat-shaming or even addict-shaming. People hate poor people.
12718098, ppl hate the poor.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 10:51 AM
yes.
12718114, I don't think this is true.
Posted by Monkey Genius, Wed Feb-04-15 11:01 AM
>poor-shaming is far more socially acceptable than fat-shaming
>or addict-shaming.

Like at all.
12718222, Me Neither
Posted by RexLongfellow, Wed Feb-04-15 11:52 AM
People fat-shame way more than "poor-shame"

Haven't heard any "addict-shaming" though...unless it's related to being a crackhead
12718229, nah, you can clown somebody for being broke
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 11:54 AM
and people will think you're less of an asshole than someone who clowns people for being fat. Broke niggas are always targets for ridicule.
12718372, Lol, that's not even close to true.
Posted by Monkey Genius, Wed Feb-04-15 01:13 PM
You maybe could clown a not-broke person about being broke. But clowning actual poor people will bring you an uppercut real quick.

Shitting on fat folks and crackheads and drunks is universally embraced across all of society.

The fact that poverty IS so hard to get out of is what makes it more taboo than the others.
12718902, Broke implies temporary. Homeless shaming I don't believe in.
Posted by Doronmonkflake, Wed Feb-04-15 09:36 PM
12718167, yes.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 11:29 AM
12718104, people will argue only one is based on genetics
Posted by T Reynolds, Wed Feb-04-15 10:57 AM
but the cross-generational affects of poverty are often overlooked on some "If I was a poor black kid" cluelessness


http://www.forbes.com/sites/quickerbettertech/2011/12/12/if-i-was-a-poor-black-kid/
12718119, depression
Posted by ALmighty44, Wed Feb-04-15 11:04 AM
.
12718123, You might as well have typed "cancer"
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 11:06 AM
12718173, I hear you. I have a family member who struggles with depression.
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 11:30 AM
It's definitely one of the most crippling and debilitating forms of disease there is.
12718143, I think addiction has the slipperiest slope
Posted by Cocobrotha2, Wed Feb-04-15 11:16 AM
You're never truly cured and you're back to square one with any setback.
12718147, i soundly disagree.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 11:18 AM
the experience will vary wildly depending on the substance or behavior involved and one's personal history, medical history, physical condition and genetics.
12718178, you forgot social status
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 11:31 AM
social status is probably the biggest factor in addiction imo. many well to do people are weekend warriors that can leave the drugs behind on Monday, yourself included, i think.
12718179, HEAVENS
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 11:32 AM
12718190, what the fuck do you be talking about?
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 11:36 AM
addiction affects every socioeconomic status equally.
12718212, Calm down lol
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 11:48 AM
There are studies on this. People with established careers and families, are not as susceptible to addiction as people living in poverty.
12718221, I agree.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 11:52 AM
>There are studies on this. People with established careers
>and families, are not as susceptible to addiction as people
>living in poverty.


Now read what you wrote up top.
12718226, I said the same thing, albeit somewhat anecdotal.
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 11:53 AM
12718262, poor ppl can be weekend warriors too.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 12:05 PM
your anecdote made it sound like
poor ppl get affected by drugs or addiction differently.





12718276, Oh, I see what you mean
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 12:14 PM
Yeah, well, a human being is a human being after all.
12718194, no. i didn't.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 11:37 AM
12718211, arrhoo?
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 11:47 AM
12718203, Yeah I made the experience sound uniform
Posted by Cocobrotha2, Wed Feb-04-15 11:42 AM
>the experience will vary wildly depending on the substance or
>behavior involved and one's personal history, medical history,
>physical condition and genetics.


But I've always understood that to beat an addiction, you had to completely abstain.

People trying to build wealth can occasionally blow some money... people trying to fight obesity can occasionally have cheat meals. Fighting addiction has always sounded all or nothing to me.

12718225, it varies by substance or behavior.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 11:53 AM
12718183, that's pretty terrible advice for many addicts.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 11:34 AM
>You're never truly cured and you're back to square one with
>any setback.


if an alcoholic that has chosen total sobriety slips and has a drink after 5 years of sobriety,
they may have a complete relapse if they view that as back to square one.


better is, you slipped up.
be sober from now on.
12718193, and plenty addicts are cured.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 11:37 AM
it depends on what substance or behavior we're talking about.

i don't agree that all addictions must be considered lifelong and all addicts are addicts forever and must be diligent everyday against sliding back into bad behavior and all that jazz.

12718198, I quit smoking 6 years ago
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 11:39 AM
I can smoke socially a couple of times a year because I'm no longer an addict.
12718223, word.
Posted by SoWhat, Wed Feb-04-15 11:52 AM
12718250, Wasn't meant as advice
Posted by Cocobrotha2, Wed Feb-04-15 12:03 PM
>>You're never truly cured and you're back to square one with
>>any setback.
>
>
>if an alcoholic that has chosen total sobriety slips and has a
>drink after 5 years of sobriety,
>they may have a complete relapse if they view that as back to
>square one.
>
>
>better is, you slipped up.
>be sober from now on.

If your goal is total sobriety, then it ended with the slip up and starts again when you renew the fight.

Anyway, I think you're inferring a defeatist tone in "You're never truly cured". This is just what I've seen expressed by some addicts struggling with sobriety... what you've expressed is how they manage to cope with that realization. Either way, an occasional indulgence is not part of their program to beat their addiction.

I wasn't thinking of all addictions though, like smoking, so YMMV.
12718267, smoking is one of THE hardest addictions to break
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 12:08 PM
and easiest to relapse. Go to a twelve step-meeting and see how many of these people who kicked alcohol/heroin/meth/coke can't kick nicotine.
12718293, I disagree with that model for overcoming addiction.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 12:27 PM
I am in the harm reduction camp.

Total abstentience is best for some ppl, and I love it for them.
But even within abstenience, I feel that identifying as an addict forever
is counterproductive.

The way you frame ideas in your mind matters.

a slip up isn't a catastrophe.
it's a mistake.

take a controled, measured response and move on.




>Anyway, I think you're inferring a defeatist tone in "You're
>never truly cured". This is just what I've seen expressed by
>some addicts struggling with sobriety... what you've expressed
>is how they manage to cope with that realization. Either way,
>an occasional indulgence is not part of their program to beat
>their addiction.
>
>I wasn't thinking of all addictions though, like smoking, so
>YMMV.
12718302, I think it depends on the addict
Posted by John Forte, Wed Feb-04-15 12:33 PM
Some people are powerless when it comes to their drug of choice.
12718329, yeah.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 12:47 PM
12718175, 1. poverty 2. addiction 3. obesity
Posted by Chanson, Wed Feb-04-15 11:31 AM
12718189, imagine the difficulties faced by ppl battlin 2or3 of those poll options
Posted by BigJazz, Wed Feb-04-15 11:36 AM
at the same damn time...


***
I'm tryna be better off, not better than...
12718206, huh man
Posted by ambient1, Wed Feb-04-15 11:43 AM
12718213, Especially since two tend to overlap the one.
Posted by Mongo, Wed Feb-04-15 11:49 AM
12718205, There are so many vehicles and mechanisms to escape addiction/obesity
Posted by Mongo, Wed Feb-04-15 11:43 AM
And still a remarkable paucity of resources to escape poverty.
12718215, None of these can truly deal with social status though
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 11:50 AM
If you're a kid living in a house where both parents are battling substance abuse problems there are very few "resources" to help you break free.
12718255, as a product of two addicts i wholeheartly disagree
Posted by tomjohn29, Wed Feb-04-15 12:04 PM
12718315, That's very impressive.
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 12:40 PM
I think that makes you a very strong person.
12718290, Factually incorrect.
Posted by Mongo, Wed Feb-04-15 12:24 PM
12718317, Can we at least agree it's not as easy?
Posted by initiationofplato, Wed Feb-04-15 12:40 PM
12718390, I'll concede it's difficult to...
Posted by Mongo, Wed Feb-04-15 01:22 PM
...fully comprehend your options under those circumstances.

To know there are options to help yourself and attain some kind of escape velocity.

I'd also concede it's an intellectual and emotional challenge to take that kind of leap of independence, and there is an avalanche of extenuating circumstances that can come down once any kind of move is made.

But it's not a foregone conclusion.
12718304, Systemic and generational Poverty can lead to addiction.
Posted by Case_One, Wed Feb-04-15 12:34 PM

.
.
.
"Today is your day to have a better life -- it's your right."
12718345, grumble grumble.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Feb-04-15 12:56 PM
12718306, poverty is the only one painted as zero-sum. less poverty = taking
Posted by Riot, Wed Feb-04-15 12:36 PM
money from my bucket

therefore i hate it and get a job, loser
12718336, Jason Voorhees
Posted by Paps_Smear, Wed Feb-04-15 12:49 PM
12718366, OKP
Posted by Government Name, Wed Feb-04-15 01:10 PM
12718932, Poverty. It takes effort, discipline and some luck to get out of it.
Posted by Shaun Tha Don, Wed Feb-04-15 10:29 PM
And many people just ain't got what it takes.