im a lil confused about what u r implying.... so lemme clarify.... my understanding is that it was highly unlikely that extremely pale Caucasian were descendants of folks from the middle east... u replied something about rape culture... I assumed u meant that those german jews had been raped by the Europeans which created pale-skinned offsprings.... iono if that's what happened but if that's the case, sorry about what ur ppl went thru... that's it...

im not about to argue about the purity of someone's jewish lineage.... or any lineage as a matter of fact... im a strong advocate of allowing ppl to define themselves for themselves... shit, I used to say I was Asiatic... so u know... mazel tov and shit...