Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectRE: that was the whole point about the inhaler fam
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13040224&mesg_id=13060706
13060706, RE: that was the whole point about the inhaler fam
Posted by Cenario, Wed Aug-24-16 12:37 PM
>I'm not sure if you read through the replies
>
>if Box is convinced this is his guy, a cold blooded murderer
>
>why would he be concerned about his health
>
>and why would he break protocol and remove evidence from a
>crime scene

The defense reasoning is bc box felt the inhaler doesn't fit. If that is true, that doesn't mean box has his doubts. That means its just one piece of evidence that doesn't fit HIS theory of how it went down. He obviously was lying about being concerned for his health. He's never once expressed his doubts about NAz being the killer, and despite his melancholy about retiring there's nothing specific that points to his having doubts.

>they established a time frame for how long it took to charge
>him
>
>if, as you say, all of the evidence points to Naz, why let him
>just hang for so long

Once the evidence that pointed to him, they arrested him, booked him, gathered more evidence and tried to get a confession. What was supposed to be different?

>
>if it was to get a confession, not giving Naz his inhaler
>could have been used as leverage
>
>some of those insinuations came out during cross, and he got
>very defensive
>
>it gives the impression that he knows Naz isn't the guy
>
>the moral play now is does he railroad Naz and live with that
>on his conscious
>
>or does he do right in his last case
>
>?
>
>I think the character's conflict is evident
>
>I think you missed the point of Naz asking 'is she dead'

I obviously understand why Naz asked if she's dead, but to the police that was evidence of how he knew info he shouldn't have known.

>
>^that's not normal for a murderer
>
>if he murdered her, why would he ask if she's dead
>
>if he's this cold-blooded killer, why would he express concern
>for his victim only moments after killing
>
>^ the question doesn't fit, that was the point

i still don't see anything that box has said/done that points to him having doubts about Naz' guilt or feeling bothered for 'railroading' him.

Being generally sad when doing things that have nothing to do with the case ain't it.
Giving naz the inhaler ain't it either.