He didn't really take to either of him.

He LOVES the old iPad though...and I heard you from the OP. But the thing is, the apps (especially kids apps and educational apps) are so much cheaper in the long run than to keep buying cartridges for the tablets.

Not to mention he can watch his Pocoyo on Youtube...if you can cop a new or even used iPad or adult tablet (someone mentioned Kindle Fire), do it. There's more options on it for the kid.

But between LeapFrog and the Innotab, I'd go with the LeapFrog