Go back to previous topic
Forum nameOkayplayer News Discussion
Topic subjectmaking a 'best of the Roots' cd is a daunting task
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=3&topic_id=185714
185714, making a 'best of the Roots' cd is a daunting task
Posted by L.E.S., Mon Aug-03-09 08:27 PM
i've been a fan of the legendary for some 15 years..

a friend of mine, not a big hip-hop head, asked me to make him a Roots mix cd.

3 factors were considered:

1. a little from each album (organix didn't make it)

2. handful of essentials (Clones, What They Do didn't make the cut)

3. my personal favorites (many of my favs didn't make the cut like

Water, Ain't Sayin Nothing New, Rising Down, Respond/React, Star

here's what i came up with.. what do yall think?

1. Proceed - DYWM
2. Section - IDHL
3. The Next Movement - TFA
4. Step Into The Realm - LIVE
5. 100% Dundee - TFA
6. Thought @ Work - PHRN
7. Here I Come - GT
8. Stay Cool - TTP
9. Sacrifice - PHRN
10. Long Time - GT
11. Act Too..Love Of My Life - TFA
12. Pussy Galore - PHRN
13. I Can't Help It - RD
14. Concerto of the Desp - IDHL
15. Don't Feel Right - GT
16. 75 Bars (Blacks Recon..) RD
17. The Seed 2.0 PHRN
18. You Got Me TFA
185715, you should add
Posted by justin_scott, Mon Aug-03-09 08:49 PM
>i've been a fan of the legendary for some 15 years..
>
>a friend of mine, not a big hip-hop head, asked me to make him
>a Roots mix cd.
>
>3 factors were considered:
>
>1. a little from each album (organix didn't make it)
>
>2. handful of essentials (Clones, What They Do didn't make the
>cut)
>
>3. my personal favorites (many of my favs didn't make the cut
>like
>
>Water, Ain't Sayin Nothing New, Rising Down, Respond/React,
>Star
>
>here's what i came up with.. what do yall think?
>
>1. Proceed - DYWM
>2. Section - IDHL
>3. The Next Movement - TFA
>4. Step Into The Realm - LIVE
>5. 100% Dundee - TFA
>6. Thought @ Work - PHRN
>7. Here I Come - GT
>8. Stay Cool - TTP
>9. Sacrifice - PHRN
>10. Long Time - GT
>11. Act Too..Love Of My Life - TFA
>12. Pussy Galore - PHRN
>13. I Can't Help It - RD
>14. Concerto of the Desp - IDHL
>15. Don't Feel Right - GT
>16. 75 Bars (Blacks Recon..) RD
>17. The Seed 2.0 PHRN
>18. You Got Me TFA


take out

don't feel right (average song)
i can't help it (nice, but not important)
75 bars (again, nice, but not better than web)
sacrifice
here i come (unless your friend is a wnba fan)

add in

what they do (great song, easily accessible)
web (thought's best "straight spitting" song)
do you want more?!?!? (shows off their range)
"the hypnotic" or "the 'notic" (both are better "thought spitting
about women" songs)
what you want
185716, eh... what they do is the only one i'm questioning
Posted by L.E.S., Mon Aug-03-09 09:06 PM
if i took off 'Here I Come' i'd replace it with 'Get Busy'

75 Bars is vital imo and better than Web. . .

Don't Feel Right isn't a favorite of mine but it feels like a representative of the GT era
185718, dont feel right got a few of my friends into the roots
Posted by Oak27, Tue Aug-04-09 12:19 AM
a good song to put on a mix for a first time listener
185772, no "what they do"? WTF, i should make a mixtape for you with nothing but
Posted by las raises, Fri Aug-07-09 02:08 AM
that song
185907, not sure if you're talking to me. it's in MY add list
Posted by justin_scott, Sun Aug-16-09 09:26 PM
.
185917, nah not you Justin i meant to reply to the original post
Posted by las raises, Mon Aug-17-09 12:22 PM
.
186007, yeah you're probably right about What They Do. .
Posted by L.E.S., Fri Aug-28-09 04:16 PM
i was thinking about saving it for a vol 2
185724, RE: making a 'best of the Roots' cd is a daunting task
Posted by ReD POet, Tue Aug-04-09 02:36 PM
give him GAMEtheory
then tell him to beg for the rest
185764, RE: making a 'best of the Roots' cd is a daunting task
Posted by Lyterall, Thu Aug-06-09 08:01 PM
I would agree, but that really goes for any "best of" type of mix. I know i made a best of Roots album a while back. I snatch tracks from every album and blended them nicely. Came out cool. Then i gave it away. Thats what i do. I made a best of Common, J Dilla, and Outkast mix, listened to them a few times and then gave em away as gifts. Spread the wealth, let everyone hear some good jams. Caring is Sharing.

Lyterall appears courtesy of
Z.F.T.P./Sign To Myself Records
(www.myspace.com/lyterall)
185769, RE: making a 'best of the Roots' cd is a daunting task
Posted by sound_quality, Fri Aug-07-09 12:36 AM
you made a best of mix and didn't include what they do? i would start the mix with that.
185802, Replace I Can't Help It and Pussy Galore
Posted by Key, Sun Aug-09-09 12:12 AM
For real I Can't Help It is probably my least favorite roots production. PG is coool and all but not greatest material. I almost want to say Sacrifice but I do love that song.
186008, no . . . I Can't Help It
Posted by L.E.S., Fri Aug-28-09 04:17 PM
get it. .

one of your least favorite? for real, that is one of the craziest, illest rap joints

of the 2000's imo
185818, J Period did a pretty good job.
Posted by KnowOne, Mon Aug-10-09 02:52 PM
nm
185836, ^^^^^Exactly^^^^ They even sell it at Best Buy
Posted by DeadMike, Tue Aug-11-09 01:54 PM
185911, Even Homegrown consists of two volumes...
Posted by Midtown Records, Mon Aug-17-09 02:59 AM
So you might want to allow yourself more than one disc.

Of course if you're using an iPod, space shouldn't matter.
185924, RE: Even Homegrown consists of two volumes...
Posted by nkulish e bulish, Tue Aug-18-09 06:30 AM

- Do you want more
- Star
- Hypnotic
- What they Do
- Long Time (Game Theory)
- Love of my Life
- Silent Treatment (Roots Come alive)
- Concerto??
- They aint saying nuthin
185971, I like the list, I may add...
Posted by NJMedStudent, Sun Aug-23-09 09:33 AM
>1. Proceed - DYWM
>2. Section - IDHL
>3. The Next Movement - TFA
>4. Step Into The Realm - LIVE
>5. 100% Dundee - TFA
>6. Thought @ Work - PHRN
>7. Here I Come - GT
>8. Stay Cool - TTP
>9. Sacrifice - PHRN
>10. Long Time - GT
>11. Act Too..Love Of My Life - TFA
>12. Pussy Galore - PHRN
>13. I Can't Help It - RD
>14. Concerto of the Desp - IDHL
>15. Don't Feel Right - GT
>16. 75 Bars (Blacks Recon..) RD
>17. The Seed 2.0 PHRN
>18. You Got Me TFA

The Spark over Pussy Galore that way you can explain what Malik B is all about plus you already have a few songs from Phrenology

Don't Say Nuthin' would also make it on there for me - I'd put that on over Don't Feel Right
186013, What they do is mandatory
Posted by soulsupreme, Sat Aug-29-09 12:18 PM
Raphael Saadiq on the hook, that's my shit.

______________________________________________________________
Blog: http://potholesinmyblog.com
Twitter: http://twitter.com/soulsupreme