Black and White got destroyed in the reviews. All of the good reviews were either paid players like 60 second film review or people hyping the film before they saw it. I don't really remember seeing many good reviews for that film.

It's actually a great comparison for She Hate Me. People who want to like it will like it. Most people won't.

On rotten tomatoes, SHM was 4 out of ten, Black and White was 4.5 (and Ebert loved both).