With Lost, there were compelling characters with interesting backstories. Even when shit didn't make any sense (i.e. many times, including the entire final season), you could still be invested in the characters. Here, things don't make sense and you don't get to know the characters over several seasons.

For the record, I enjoyed Lost until the final season which was terrible, but I fully acknowledge how full of shit the writers who claim there was a plan are. There was obviously no plan.