I think the biggest problem with Batman Begins (a movie I thought was great in theaters and later bought) is that it had been so long since a decent Batman movie had come out.

Batman is my favorite comic book superhero, but even on my first viewing of Begins there were several flawed aspects (that didn't involve Katie Holmes, either).

and I *still* like X-2 better. that's the definitive comic book movie to date, IMO.