I loved Jennifer Hudson when she was on AI...I was impressed with her performance as a whole but something about that scene just didn't grab me. Maybe it was because I heard her version before I saw the movie and that took something away.

Overall, I just wasn't impressed with the movie. I plan on seeing it again though because my theater was full of retards who either didn't know that Dreamgirls was a musical or that musical involve singing. They ended up groaning, huffing and puffing everytime someone would break into song. That affected my enjoyability...

I really wanted to like it...After my second viewing I'll come back here and either reconfirm my displeasure or rescind my opinion.

But for right now..I thought the scene was over the top. No more, no less.