Go back to previous topic
Forum nameOkay Activist Archives
Topic subject.....
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=22&topic_id=7887&mesg_id=7956
7956, .....
Posted by Jennyfer, Wed Jun-26-02 10:42 PM
However, in arts gaining much popularity in
>the West such as t'ai chi and capoeira, this is not
>possible. In t'ai chi, the accompanying religion/philosophy
>is Taoism. How do the big 3 see/understand concepts of
>"chi" and "ying-yang"?

Well a Christian may understand these two concepts. But what a Christian can't do is agree that the Energy of Chi or the balance of Ying-yang exists. By stating that only movements of T'ai Chi can be learned or studied by anyone that claims Christianity. I would deem a Christian T'ai chi practicer similar to Atheists that attend a Lutheran School.



These concepts clearly cannot be
>understood by the big 3, "ying-yang" especially, because it
>nullifies the existence of "God vs. Devil."

Well once again understanding the concept may be attainable.
Just like someone who's a non-believer to the Big 3 may understand concepts within them, even tho they don't believe it to be true. Believing it to be true is the line of demarcation that separates Christian vs. Taoist. Solarus I'm pretty sure you understand that you can't be Christian and practice Tao at the same time. (Hence the post) But if you do the movements only religous aspect may be separated.


In capoeira,
>_EVERYTHING_ (let me say this again) _EVERYTHING_ is tied to
>an orisha; the instruments, music, movements, rituals,
>_EVERYTHING_! Capoeira and Candomble are sisters with the
>same Afrikan parents. In fact capoeira is a religion within
>itself. *My favorite quote from an angolero: "Church?! I
>don't need church! I got capoeira!"

If there's no way to separate it ...then it's a no can do.


>Knowing what was previously stated, how does a practitioner
>of one of the big three JUSTIFY practicing and studying one
>of the aforementioned as they go against their own
>teachings?

Some i've heard were for exercise (Yoga). Most common Self-defense. We would probably agree that a Christian Practicer would not be as emmersed in these arts as someone who believes it with all of their heart.