to me its the question can inorganic matter turn into organic matter and then become 'live' on its own...

even the most basic living organism is PRETTY DAMN complex....so even if we imagine that through random events and environmental happenings that physically something like a cell is formed...

can u just fit the physical materials together and the cell will take life on its own?

add some carbon, nitrogen, phosphates, and oxygen...piece them together...will this organism automatically start ingesting material for food, know how to reproduce, etc etc...