In the 'Do you guys hate the white man?' forum you propose that we should not ask the black man this but rather we should ask if the white man if he hates the black man. You justify this on the grounds that you would never ask the victimiser if he hated the victim. In this sense you suggest that the way to address black issues is in part via a white account and subsequent understanding of white supremacy.

Notwithstanding the diametric crudeness of this idea, at what point do you seek to silence the individual you choose to quiz in the first place?