Go back to previous topic
Forum nameOkay Activist Archives
Topic subjectPlease, just show me that you are at least trying to focus...
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=22&topic_id=27306&mesg_id=27322
27322, Please, just show me that you are at least trying to focus...
Posted by Pinko_Panther, Sat Feb-26-05 06:55 AM
First of all, no where in my last statement did I mention anything about socialism -nowhere! Sure, I am a socialist but could you at least wait until that comes up before you decide that you are going to base your whole counter argument on it?

Second you make such strong claims about this phenomenon you call "human nature". Human nature arguments are write off statements for people who don't want to think something through. Personally, I don't believe that there is such a thing as human nature. History has shown us that we behave according to our social structures. There are as many examples of cooperation and unity as there is for division and conflict. In a society where the dogmatic view of human beings is one of individualism and accumulation through greed and competition we are going to have greedy and competitive people. These are learned behaviours not natural ones. If you don't believe me then tell me why 14 hour work days were acceptable 100 years ago but we would regard such a work day with disgust today? Why did American society believe slavery was acceptable 200 years ago but is deplored today? Why weren't women allowed to vote at the turn of the 20th century but now they can? Could these changes possibly have anything to do with the consciousness of people changing as we have collectively fought for them and rearranged the way we live our lives?

Your little claim about humans being nothing but mere animals is as equally unprofound. First of all, if we are the same as most animals, most species of animals do not survive at the expense of other animals within their species. Most animals cooperate for survival. Furthermore, human beings are different from other animals for the sheer fact that we consciously produce things whereas other animals produce instinctively. How many wolves have programmed computers? How many lions have built enormous bridges across large bodies of water?

If what you are attempting to say is true then why even struggle for racial unity? If someone is going to eff things up for everyone else, then surely this applies to the black movement and the womens movement too, no? Why should we reject the war in Iraq? Hell, by your logic Bush is the perfect person in power! Heil frickin Hitler! Come to think of it, I remember you once said that you were once quite a republican. I can see why, the logic is still there.

>It claims to eliminate differences and societal evils and
>level the playing field. The problem is human nature.
>People will always seek adavantage and group together based
>on that. We are animals. There is no escaping that. Sure
>we are responsible fo our thoughts and actions, and so what?
> In the end someone will eff up the system. I'd rather have
>my bs right up front where I can see it.
>
>
>
>______________________________
>
>Instores Feb. 8th NothernArc's very own Black Bill
>Gate's
>Hosted By John Legend.
>
>
>
>
>
>_________________
>Inaug'ral Member of the OkaySports Hall of Fame.