>Guys that have actually played the position like Warren Moon,
>Kurt Warner, Steve Young & Dan Marino disagree. Saying any QB
>with a 4-1 TD/Int ratio isn't helping his team win is
>borderline crazy talk imo.

look, obviously the guy is playing solid. its the reason we are having the discussion (he was so horrible in the past that he is actually showing signs of life now). but he is still not playing to his potential. i still see him make high throws more often than he should. and, as i've been saying, his lack of attempts per game is validation that the coaching staff is aware of this.

if thats reason enough for alex smith haters to 'take their L', okay. i'm just pointing shit out. i don't really care for his haters or his fans either way. which would bring us to a different argument of 'what defines taking an L for a smith'.

>And JC has 2 more ints and 2 less TDs in only 7 more
>attempts... so acting like they would be 5-1 with him as a
>given really don't add up.

hey its close. and one of JC's picks was from a hail mary attempt.