>Shaun Hill and Alex Smith have almost identical passer
>ratings this season... The "he just wins argument" don't even
>work anymore, dude is 2-7 as a starter this year.
he was 10-6 as a starter on THIS team. also better TD-INT ratio than alex but I'm talking about WINNING. he's the only fucking QB WITH a winning record since garcia.

>I'm willing to say Alex has to move on but for the love of god
>will you people stop talking like Shaun Hill was anything
>worth crying over
why are you MAD at Hill? Is he a crisp clean downfield passer? As athletic as Alex? The long term solution? No on all counts. HOWEVER, FOR THE TIME BEING, I believe he would have won MORE games than Alex did. And this is DESPITE all the other crazy shit that Sing has presided over. In a year when the divison is woefully bad and the Rams and Seahawks are going to get better, we could have won the division and gone to the playoffs. Like we all agree, letting the wheels fall off may be the best long term scenario, but in the interim, we'd be a winner with Hill.