>Not even in the Ivy League.
>
>My argument is not that he isn't clutch, or that he hasn't
>finally learned to cut down on the arm punts. It's just that,
>he has never had a single season comparable to his
>contemporaries that are in that elite class.
>
>Best Giants QB ever, probably without a doubt. A guy you would
>want as your franchise QB? Yes.
>
>Elite? No way.
>
>He's probably closer to Brett Favre than anyone else.