I agree with that - but at the same time, it makes the magazine more definite with their shit, making them look like they're taking more of a stance. Essentially, that's hip-hop - putting it out there as is, no in between, and take it or leave it.

For the most part (and you can take it for what it's worth, I just started writing for their web site though haha), aside from the review of Tony Yayo's album, I actually agree with XXL's reviews for the most part. Still, a review is only one person/publication's opinion; I'm going to check for Idlewild regardless, and judge it for myself.