Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson Archives
Topic subjectRE: hmmmm pt. 2
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=17&topic_id=30950&mesg_id=30962
30962, RE: hmmmm pt. 2
Posted by SoWhat, Thu Nov-29-01 02:37 PM
>>Some music is targeted at certain
>>cultures w/o being parts of
>>it.
>>
>>2 examples:
>>
>>Britney Spears - music made by
>>older men in Sweden, targeted
>>at (US) teen culture.
>>
>
>well not to start another britany
>debate but its her face
>on the album cover and
>its her voice, so isnt
>that operating within us teen
>culture?

We're talking about the music and where it comes from, right? Her music, her songs...the whole thing came from outside the culture being targeted.

Want genuine teen music? Check for the Beastie's 1st album.

>>Average White Band - made music
>>associated w/Black (American) culture, but
>>they weren't part of it.
>>
>
>interesting
>
>but whose fault is it? the
>band's or the fans?

Umm...the band's. Or their parents. Or whatever.

I mean, as far as I know they weren't part of Black culture, but they made "Black music". I could be wrong...I'm assuming they weren't part of the culture cuz they weren't Black.

>i mean they played as close
>as you can get to
>authentic music it was just
>that the fans of the
>original music didnt accept them
>into their culture.

It takes more than making music to be accepted into a culture. I could make a bomb assed piece of Bhangra...but I'm not going to be accepted as an Indian b/c of it. You know?

>but dont they understand street culture,
>if they didnt how could
>their music be accepted there?

We're talking about the music coming FROM the culture, right?