Go back to previous topic | Forum name | The Lesson Archives | Topic subject | RE: allright, but if the result is still good? | Topic URL | http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=17&topic_id=14189&mesg_id=14202 |
14202, RE: allright, but if the result is still good? Posted by okayyac, Thu Jul-10-03 10:41 AM
>Whatever your opinion of it I don't think that cut is >Hip-Hop in the first place. > >IMO if the vocals on the record has only singing instead of >rapping it's not Hip-Hop, regardless of the beat. Maybe >you can call it "Hip-Hop Soul" like they like to call Mary >J's music. > >If the record is an instrumental there should be samples >throughout the track. Unless you don't believe in >instrumental Hip-Hop and like using that term "Trip-Hop" >some people use. > >There has to be an MC and/or DJ in there somewhere for it to >be Hip-Hop. >
LOL...I love when cats make this neat and tidy definition of hip-hop and how it should be and sound. So what if the new Kast isn't hip-hop anyway, should it matter? if they're putting out good music, are u really that closed-minded that you only want them to make hip-hop?
i'm gonna steal somethin from OKP Clark Kent who happens to hate me fiercely but made a great point- hip-hop was founded on breaking the rules. it doesn't have a strict definition...its whatever u want it to be.
| |