Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #726353

Subject: "Aside from the the obvious CG issues with the girl, this looks okay" Previous topic | Next topic
obsidianchrysalis
Member since Jan 29th 2003
8751 posts
Wed Jul-25-18 12:45 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
23. "Aside from the the obvious CG issues with the girl, this looks okay"
In response to In response to 22


  

          

My question is, why mix the live action with the CG main character?

The other androids have human faces matched with CG bodies, why didn't Alita have the same?

Or why is Alita the only CG character and the other actors performances are filmed?

This movie is in some weird shaky ground where it's neither CG cartoon or live action movie, when the story might work better if it were either of the two.

Maybe the technology powering Alita seemed promising in pre-production and so the production moved forward with the filmmakers thinking the CG techniques could be perfected over the length of the production?

Also, is the source material basically YA? For some reason when the news dropped that this was being made, when Cameron was attached, it seemed that the graphic novel this is based on (?) was darker than the tone that was described in this trailer. Rodriquez and the producers can do whatever they want with the original story but this just seemed geared towards 13-year olds in the same way that Avatar was. The way the pre-production press told it, this movie was going to be more graphic and dramatic.

<--- Me when my head hits the pillow

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Alita: Battle Angel (Robert Rodriguez, 2018) [View all] , bwood, Fri Dec-08-17 04:00 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
the first 2 seconds made me want to turn it off. WTF
Dec 08th 2017
1
Has the same thoughts. Shit gave me nightmares...
Dec 09th 2017
10
is there a creative reason why only the main character looks manga-ish?
Dec 08th 2017
2
Because she's a robot and the others aren't?
Dec 08th 2017
3
      there are cyborgs in the trailer with normal human faces tho.
Dec 08th 2017
4
NOPE! Im already creeped out
Dec 08th 2017
5
Im not mad at it, but the CGI isn't there yet for what they trying to do
Dec 08th 2017
6
I like that they are taking that chance.
Dec 08th 2017
7
I'm honestly getting bored / tired with spec fic
Dec 09th 2017
8
Nope. THIS IS OUR TIME CYBERPUNK NERDS
Dec 09th 2017
9
RE: prayer hands emoji
Dec 13th 2017
16
What's redundant are the storylines...not the genre
Dec 10th 2017
11
      RE: fair
Dec 13th 2017
15
Rodriguez with a budget? I'm down.
Dec 11th 2017
12
They should have just adapted Windup Girl instead.
Dec 11th 2017
13
The trailer looks okay.
Dec 12th 2017
14
people need to make movies that aren't $100 million
Dec 13th 2017
17
I know nothing about the source material, but I don't like the eyes thin...
Dec 13th 2017
18
this looks like a train wreck and i can’t wait to watch it.
Dec 13th 2017
19
AKA, Real Doll: The Movie
Dec 13th 2017
20
Everything about this looks trash
Dec 21st 2017
21
Alita: Battle Angel | Official Trailer
Jul 23rd 2018
22
      she's not human...so the CG actually serves a purpose in this case
Jul 27th 2018
24
           Oh, okay.
Jul 29th 2018
25
This has a lot in common with Aquaman
Feb 12th 2019
26
Liked it. Great visuals, earnest story, lots of silly/cool action.
Feb 15th 2019
27
Can I see this in 2D or must I see the 3D?
Feb 18th 2019
28
RE: Can I see this in 2D or must I see the 3D?
Feb 18th 2019
29
BOOOOOO!!!!!!!
Feb 18th 2019
31
3D didn't do much for me but didn't see it via IMAX either
Feb 18th 2019
30
      I thought the IMAX 3D owned.
Feb 18th 2019
32
So much of this movie is dumb, but main girl is oddly compelling.
Feb 19th 2019
33
oddly compelling is spot on
Feb 19th 2019
34
      Yeah, very good voice acting for her.
Feb 19th 2019
35

Lobby Pass The Popcorn topic #726353 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com