Okayplayer.com Boards - Viewing message

Printer-friendly copy

Email this topic to a friend

Lobby

Pass The Popcorn

topic #297660

Subject: "i wasn't to thrillied about this one..."

This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic

dunk
Member since Aug 05th 2006
8017 posts

Sat Jul-14-07 12:36 AM

Click to send private message to this author

Click to add this author to your buddy list

62. "i wasn't to thrillied about this one..."
In response to In response to 0

..the editing seemed awkward

the stuff left ot of this one bothered me as well

i mean, i can understand that i you have to take stuff out but this one felt emotionless and they seem to take the lie out of the story when cutting out the sub plots from the book.

Ron and Hermoine felt very underused in this one, with Neville and Luna standing out more than them. it just felt awkward.

GOF and Askaban have been the best to me so far.

Printer-friendly copy

The Official Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix post [View all] , Melanism, Mon Jul-09-07 08:20 AM

Subject	Author	Message Date	ID
New writer and a new director	SienaBlaze	Jul 09th 2007	1
Wednesday IMAX check-in.	ZooTown74	Jul 09th 2007	2
same	Michi	Jul 09th 2007	4
FUCK! All the IMAX showings except for 10 and 12 AM are SOLD OUT in NYC	Melanism	Jul 10th 2007	7
did you try Garden City?	SienaBlaze	Jul 10th 2007	9
pops collar	Damali	Jul 11th 2007	15
does anyone else think the films really pale in comparison	Science_Fiction	Jul 09th 2007	3
Yeah, pretty much	mrhood75	Jul 09th 2007	5
I agree	SienaBlaze	Jul 10th 2007	10
I have to go see it by myself...	lovelyone80	Jul 09th 2007	6
The reviews	J Fabuluz	Jul 10th 2007	8
I'm excited about seeing this film...	earthseed	Jul 10th 2007	11
I saw it monday night.	cormon	Jul 10th 2007	12
I'm pissed that I couldn't make the midnight show. :(	Frank Longo	Jul 10th 2007	13
I just got back from a theater in Burbank	ZooTown74	Jul 11th 2007	14
Saw it last night... (Spoiler.....kinda)	hilfger21	Jul 11th 2007	16
cats got problems with this	MisterGrump	Jul 11th 2007	18
the best HP movie to date	dkos22	Jul 11th 2007	17
RE: The Official Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix post	Abraham	Jul 11th 2007	19
I liked the new Harold the Potna movie (n/m)	Allah	Jul 11th 2007	20
what trailer was it + 10,000 BC (that fantasy trailer) oh yeah Stardust	Allah	Jul 11th 2007	21
i liked the novel but i dunno about this movie thing	rob	Jul 11th 2007	23
SERIOUSLY cant wait!	Ms_MynTight	Jul 11th 2007	22
It was okay, but something felt off (SPOILERS)	ZooTown74	Jul 11th 2007	24
imelda staunton was okay, imo.	WhiteNotion	Jul 11th 2007	26
RE: It was okay, but something felt off (SPOILERS)	2nd2Nun	Jul 12th 2007	30
on Draco:	Damali	Jul 12th 2007	31
you're right	2nd2Nun	Jul 12th 2007	40
RE: It was okay, but something felt off (SPOILERS)	tappenzee	Jul 17th 2007	73
Imelda Staunton played Dolores Umbridge.	ZooTown74	Jul 17th 2007	75
oh right right	tappenzee	Jul 18th 2007	81
well,	Invisiblist	Jul 11th 2007	25
RE: well,	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 12th 2007	37
just got back from seeing it. best one yet, i think	bobbyjames	Jul 11th 2007	27
RE: just got back from seeing it. best one yet, i think	J Fabuluz	Jul 12th 2007	28
this one and Prisoner of Azkaban are my favorites	bobbyjames	Jul 12th 2007	43
some things i noticed:	Damali	Jul 12th 2007	29
My girlfriend said the same thing about Maggie	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 12th 2007	38
Seamus is Scottish, not Irish.	Invisiblist	Jul 12th 2007	45
thanks. I always get those two mixed up	Damali	Jul 12th 2007	46
don't worry	Invisiblist	Jul 12th 2007	49
no, he's Irish	Michi	Jul 17th 2007	74
i enjoyed it	zero	Jul 12th 2007	32
I read somewhere	SienaBlaze	Jul 12th 2007	35
mixed feelings	jane eyre	Jul 12th 2007	33
what did you think of book 6?	Damali	Jul 12th 2007	34
RE: what did you think of book 6?	jane eyre	Jul 12th 2007	52
This was my least favorite of the books, but the movie was alright	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 12th 2007	36
wrong reply.	Invisiblist	Jul 12th 2007	47
Question For Those Who Saw It (spoilers I guess)	Melanism	Jul 12th 2007	39
oooooh that's juicy!!! (spoilers)	Damali	Jul 12th 2007	41
Luna is probably going to be the main love interest	Invisiblist	Jul 12th 2007	48
luna had too big of a part in the movie	WhiteNotion	Jul 12th 2007	53
Kreacher?	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 12th 2007	42
According to wikipedia...	_Ignorance_Is_Venemous_	Jul 12th 2007	44
it's gotta be Kreacher. I'll tell you why.	Invisiblist	Jul 12th 2007	50
You mean the locket?	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 12th 2007	51
yeah, the locket that wasn't at the bottom of the bowl.	Latina212	Jul 17th 2007	76
very very nice.	Damali	Jul 12th 2007	54
Could be Bellatrix (swipe)	ZooTown74	Jul 13th 2007	56
Bellatrix was always in the OOTP movie because....	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 13th 2007	57
I forgot to give you some context regarding her above comments	ZooTown74	Jul 13th 2007	58
i see what you mean	BrooklynWHAT	Jul 13th 2007	61
RE: The Official Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix post	Stryfe	Jul 13th 2007	55
i don't agree	xangeluvr	Jul 13th 2007	59
hated gof witha passion	Stryfe	Jul 14th 2007	63
Good but not the best	Michi	Jul 13th 2007	60

just how i felt	xangeluvr	Jul 14th 2007	64
I liked it until the end (Spoilers)	SienaBlaze	Jul 14th 2007	65
I actually liked how they handled it (spoilers)	Melanism	Jul 16th 2007	70
didn't like it.	shygurl	Jul 15th 2007	66
Not a good stand-alone, but good for the series	KingMonte	Jul 15th 2007	67
I think this is the best movie so far. ESPECIALLY in light of the fact t...	Frank Longo	Jul 15th 2007	68
I was dragged into seeing this	will_5198	Jul 15th 2007	69
RE: I was dragged into seeing this SPOILER!!!!!!!	Abraham	Jul 17th 2007	71
LOL at Serious Black!!!!!	BigWorm	Jul 17th 2007	72
3rd movie > 5th movie > 4th movie > 1st 2 movies	Frank Longo	Jul 17th 2007	78
Agree and agree	JungleSouljah	Jul 19th 2007	83
RE: The Official Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix post	deacon	Jul 17th 2007	77
did you guys notice dumbledore as the bartender???	Latina212	Jul 17th 2007	79
huh? you mean at the first d.a. meeting?	2nd2Nun	Jul 18th 2007	80
whoa. i didn't notice that at all	Damali	Jul 19th 2007	82
they are listed as diff actors in the credits	JBoogs	Jul 20th 2007	84
it's Dumbledore's brother, Aberforth, not Albus...	JBoogs	Jul 20th 2007	85
up	janey	Jul 24th 2007	86
this is about the movie.	unity	Jul 24th 2007	87

Lobby

Pass The Popcorn

topic #297660

Previous topic | Next topic