Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2907794

Subject: "I view the Thicke song and the Marvin Gaye song to be" Previous topic | Next topic
Warren Coolidge
Charter member
41998 posts
Fri Oct-31-14 10:41 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
10. "I view the Thicke song and the Marvin Gaye song to be"
In response to In response to 7


  

          

similar enough to say that this legal action is more than reasonable... I don't see this at all as some abstract similarity where someone is just trying to cash it....

on a basic level the songs sound the same....almost sampled...

and lets remember that Thicke and thems side initiated a legal action...kind of rang like a guilty person being initially extra defensive thinking they would have the edge because they would have access to higher priced lawyers.....

it didn't work out for them..


but again..

add a little more creativity to what you do.... the "making beats" mentality in R&B at some point is always going to risk copying or redo-ing previous tracks because you're not dealing with production coming mostly from composed music played by multiple musicians..along with those musicians individual musicianship....

it's a hazard of the current game

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


god don't like ugly (marvin gaye vs robbing thicke & pharrell) [View all] , fire, Fri Oct-31-14 02:47 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
I hope the Gayes lose.
Oct 30th 2014
1
Me too.
Oct 30th 2014
2
I hope producers and artists get more original...n/m
Oct 30th 2014
3
I hope you realize how ridiculous this sounds.
Oct 31st 2014
5
I hope you realize how riddiculous it sounds to have a
Oct 31st 2014
8
      I hope you realize that if they actually end up...
Oct 31st 2014
12
           or like if my favorite producer makes a beat that
Oct 31st 2014
14
                Yep. So fucking frivolous and obnoxious.
Oct 31st 2014
17
A grip of your favorites would be affected by this.
Oct 31st 2014
7
     
      i bet you do.
Oct 31st 2014
11
           they went ON record IN print SEVERAL times
Oct 31st 2014
15
                they didn't use any copyrighted material
Oct 31st 2014
16
                RE: they didn't use any copyrighted material
Oct 31st 2014
19
                I think with the way the music is made today....
Nov 01st 2014
22
                There's 3 billion artists....
Oct 31st 2014
18
                     no man
Oct 31st 2014
21
      ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ exxxxxxxxxxxxxxxactly.
Oct 31st 2014
13
This means nothing.
Oct 31st 2014
4
      Going to court doesn't exactly mean "nothing"
Oct 31st 2014
6
           they got nothing and will most likely lose.
Oct 31st 2014
9
           RE: Going to court doesn't exactly mean "nothing"
Oct 31st 2014
20

Lobby The Lesson topic #2907794 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com