Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2925415

Subject: ""classic" vs "masterpiece"" Previous topic | Next topic
Mr. ManC
Member since Jan 26th 2009
11819 posts
Fri Mar-27-15 02:20 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
""classic" vs "masterpiece""
Fri Mar-27-15 02:40 PM by Mr. ManC

  

          

With TPAB and T&Y as recent markers for recently released GREAT albums, I'm wondering if we should start breaking up the "classic" designation for albums into the "classic"/"masterpiece" option.

I love both albums, but if someone were to say "those aren't classic albums" I would probably agree. But there needs to be a category for this kind of achievement. It feels like classics meet the expectations of the waiting public, are are bonafide hits that enter into pop culture familiarity. Masterpieces though feel like they meet the expectations of the artists. It is a shared personal achievement opposed to a disseminated social accomplishment.

TPAB, T&Y, The Ecstatic....personally these albums aren't necessarily "classic" but they are definitely masterpieces, and I think I prefer them to actual standalone classic achievements.

What say you?

________________________________________________
R.I.P. Soulgyal <3
SUPA NERD LLC.
Knowledge Meets Nature
Musica Negra
#13irteen

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


"classic" vs "masterpiece" [View all] , Mr. ManC, Fri Mar-27-15 02:20 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
good distinction
Mar 27th 2015
1
Agreed, for the most part.
Mar 27th 2015
3
      yup!
Mar 27th 2015
4
      That's dope.
Mar 27th 2015
9
      I think albums like TPaB are reference points
Mar 27th 2015
8
           Yep. We are in agreement.
Mar 27th 2015
10
Big fan of this distinction.
Mar 27th 2015
2
yeah, I feel like it's the difference between like
Mar 27th 2015
7
great post; i've always used the distinction the same way
Mar 27th 2015
5
I used to use the term "personal classic"
Mar 27th 2015
6
"Masterpiece" is about words and sounds.
Mar 27th 2015
11
true, but "classic" can also denote infamy.
Mar 31st 2015
19
I've used Masterpiece to describe the culmination of a genre
Mar 29th 2015
12
RE: I've used Masterpiece to describe the culmination of a genre
Mar 31st 2015
21
the term "instant classic" is an oxymoron
Mar 30th 2015
13
I thought this too, but when I looked up the definition...
Mar 30th 2015
14
      From Webster
Mar 31st 2015
15
           Where the hell were the definitions I saw then? HAha
Mar 31st 2015
16
                Oh no I didn't take it like that at all, my man
Mar 31st 2015
18
                     Word. And I'm in the same boat.
Mar 31st 2015
20
masterpiece makes sense for current AND old stuff...
Mar 31st 2015
17

Lobby The Lesson topic #2925415 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com