Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Sports Okay Sports Archives topic #103191

Subject: "Barnes vs. Kidd-Gilchrist - Who will be the better NBA player?" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
ThaTruth
Charter member
99998 posts
Thu May-31-12 10:27 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"Poll question: Barnes vs. Kidd-Gilchrist - Who will be the better NBA player?"
Thu May-31-12 10:27 AM by ThaTruth

          

Poll result (43 votes)
Barnes (16 votes)Vote
MKG (26 votes)Vote
I'd rather have a Plumlee (a.k.a. I'm white) (1 votes)Vote

  

  

Printer-friendly copy


Barnes vs. Kidd-Gilchrist - Who will be the better NBA player? [View all] , ThaTruth, Thu May-31-12 10:27 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
NBA Draft 2012: Comparing Michael Kidd-Gilchrist and Harrison Barnes
May 31st 2012
1
This is forreal? Like you're using Bleacher Report?
May 31st 2012
2
      LOLOLOLOLOL
May 31st 2012
3
      Its just an example of one of several googleable comparisions...
May 31st 2012
5
      lol
May 31st 2012
65
Barnes will end up on the Bucks
May 31st 2012
4
RE: Barnes will end up on the Bucks
May 31st 2012
6
these assholes need to STOP propping SouthChapelMan.
May 31st 2012
7
I depends on the situation he lands in, I think his game is more...
May 31st 2012
8
      What happened in college then?
May 31st 2012
10
           LOL
May 31st 2012
14
           it was "in college"?
May 31st 2012
15
                So he was too advanced to be good in college. I got it.
May 31st 2012
18
                     You're not really that dumb, are you? Jonny Flynn was thought...
May 31st 2012
21
                          I think you can't possibly be that dense about the box scores you watch
May 31st 2012
28
                               At the end of the day, Harrison was better and more consistent...
May 31st 2012
30
                                    Cuz he was on a team that needed him to score genius.
May 31st 2012
31
                                         lol, you're a kentucky nuthugger and think every player from there...
May 31st 2012
32
                                              Greatest thing since sliced bread....Really?
May 31st 2012
33
                                                   RE: Greatest thing since sliced bread....Really?
May 31st 2012
38
                                                        Please, I've forgotten more about the NBA than you know.
May 31st 2012
40
                                                             lol, okayplayer...
May 31st 2012
45
                                                                  You mean the Bulls that had the best record in the league?
May 31st 2012
47
                                                                       RE: You mean the Bulls that had the best record in the league?
May 31st 2012
54
Barnes reminds me of Calbert Cheaney
May 31st 2012
9
Thought the same thing (Cheaney)....
May 31st 2012
13
MKG will be a better pro
May 31st 2012
11
gimme the South Jersey kid, dont think hes got a chance of being a star
May 31st 2012
12
MKG is more like Brandan Wright than Barnes
May 31st 2012
19
Nah Wright was mentally/physically soft like Barnes shows signs of being
May 31st 2012
22
to be fair
May 31st 2012
23
      brotha I grew up in NJ, u kno u dont need to educate me on Saint Anthony
May 31st 2012
52
No, he's not
May 31st 2012
35
as far as more athleticism than skill, yes
May 31st 2012
39
      I honestly don't see that. MKG isn't short on skill
May 31st 2012
43
           Cosign. There's a reason he shot nearly 50% last year.
May 31st 2012
44
                That's the thing, he's not going to get those easy buckets around...
May 31st 2012
46
                     So do tell how Barnes will get get good looks in the NBA...
May 31st 2012
48
                     ^^^ this, lol. If MKG will struggle getting looks...
May 31st 2012
49
                     Barnes has J, MKG doesn't, simple as that, I'm not saying Barnes...
May 31st 2012
55
                          A guy that fast and big isn't easily checked.
May 31st 2012
56
                          umm...you just back up off of him and say "shoot"
May 31st 2012
60
                          An inconsistent jumper that is even moreso when defended
May 31st 2012
57
                               I said he can make you pay if you leave him open, say he winds up...
May 31st 2012
61
                     yes he will
May 31st 2012
51
                     a little?
May 31st 2012
66
                          'casm?
May 31st 2012
67
Huh? He plays nothing like Brandan Wright.
May 31st 2012
36
having played hsbb v. dajuan ~~
Jul 15th 2012
82
MKG is a little more skilled then folks are saying imo
May 31st 2012
16
mkg easy.
May 31st 2012
17
I don't see how Barnes is gonna be any good
May 31st 2012
20
The NBA is a scorers' league, you have specialists out there like...
May 31st 2012
24
      Being the SF Tony Allen wouldn't be the worst thing in the world
May 31st 2012
25
      but Tony Allen is more of a role-player type that as has kind of...
May 31st 2012
27
      it's easier to develop a jumper than to resurrect a corpse
May 31st 2012
53
MKG...not a star but a very good, multi-faceted wing player
May 31st 2012
26
Blue all day I'm just not sold on Barnes
May 31st 2012
29
Their games are absolutely NOTHING alike, lol.
May 31st 2012
34
nobody said they were, but as the top 2 wing prospects in the draft...
May 31st 2012
41
MKG is the next Terrence Williams.
May 31st 2012
37
No
May 31st 2012
50
Psst... are y'all noticing the UNC fans in here... picking MKG?
May 31st 2012
42
Barnes easily
May 31st 2012
58
what does 'not playing OC' mean?
May 31st 2012
59
      the muslim cats are ok but the others get the side eye from me too...
May 31st 2012
62
      man ain't nobody talking about Lew Alcindor
May 31st 2012
63
I think both players can be studs in the league...
May 31st 2012
64
Nowadays I think people over analyze and caught up on potential...
Jun 01st 2012
68
*mental notes*
Jul 14th 2012
69
After a 5 - 17 shooting performance?
Jul 14th 2012
70
we'll see. n/m
Jul 14th 2012
71
I thought you said summer league don't mean shit....?
Jul 14th 2012
72
      It doesn't.
Jul 14th 2012
73
      Cool. So you just wanted to say mental notes for no reason?
Jul 14th 2012
74
           we'll see. n/m
Jul 14th 2012
75
                Now you're on your "vague response to valid points" schtick
Jul 14th 2012
77
                     I mean we can go back and forth about or we can wait until...
Jul 15th 2012
80
      Basically
Jul 14th 2012
76
I'd take Barnes every time down
Jul 14th 2012
78
basically...
Jul 15th 2012
79
Only if UNC could've used a guy that could get buckets...
Jul 15th 2012
81
and barnes is a good defender on top of that
Jul 15th 2012
86
if MKG ever gets a jumper it won't be close
Jul 15th 2012
83
And if he doesn't?
Jul 15th 2012
84
      closer
Jul 15th 2012
85
Barnes.
Jul 16th 2012
87
I'm never sold on "high motor-hustle" guys
Jul 16th 2012
88
Barnes. he seems to have a defined skill, MKG not so much.
Jul 16th 2012
89
nice to see more ppl coming over to Team Barnes
Jul 16th 2012
90
when I bumped this post on Saturday it was 14-4 MKG
Jul 16th 2012
91
      damn i thought you just made this post. it all makes sense now
Jul 16th 2012
92
      yea i ride with MKG too cause he's basically from philly
Jul 16th 2012
93
           Quotes and quotes and quotes
Jul 16th 2012
94
This is going to be interesting
Oct 25th 2012
95
haven't seen barnes in the preseason yet but everyone is acting
Oct 25th 2012
96
      actually, no it wasn't...it's been barnes v. MKG since high school
Oct 25th 2012
97
           Basa-L
Dec 17th 2014
238
MKG.
Oct 25th 2012
98
Barnes impacts nothing on either end.
Nov 10th 2012
99
and the Bobcats spent a #2 pick on a hustle player
Nov 10th 2012
100
      Nope. Golden State drafted a player who's better working for Audible.com...
Nov 10th 2012
101
           If MKG is one of your top 2 players you're not making the playoff
Nov 10th 2012
102
                Is this your way of extending your inevitable Wrong?
Nov 10th 2012
103
                Yeah, because Rookies NEVER improve.
Nov 10th 2012
104
                     oh he on the Evan Turner development plan now?
Nov 10th 2012
105
                     no one calla john wall a bust...
Nov 10th 2012
107
                     so All-Star in 2 years? got it.
Nov 10th 2012
106
                          Didn't say that, Moron.
Nov 10th 2012
108
                               "damn good player" is kinda ambiguous, care to elaborate?
Nov 10th 2012
109
MKG
Nov 10th 2012
110
good game
Nov 10th 2012
111
      good game? nigga, that was a dominant performance
Nov 11th 2012
112
           you're trying too hard
Nov 11th 2012
115
Warriors fan here, haven't missed a game all season.. it's easily MKG
Nov 11th 2012
113
http://www.boxing-kit.com/images/uploads/wil1418.jpg
Nov 11th 2012
114
Barnes balled out tonight!
Nov 14th 2012
116
what have we learned? his best not better than MKG's best
Nov 15th 2012
117
It was last night
Nov 15th 2012
119
      that his BEST game. gilly might average that soon.
Nov 15th 2012
120
           LOL, damn you for this:
Nov 15th 2012
121
Mkg making bobcats better
Nov 15th 2012
118
18 and 9 while klay gunned
Nov 16th 2012
122
Warriors fan here, watched every game so far - summer and reg season.
Nov 17th 2012
123
don't get scared now mf's!
Nov 19th 2012
124
This debate is boring & I've moved on.
Nov 19th 2012
125
http://www.ejection-history.org.uk/0000/f4phtm.jpg
Nov 19th 2012
127
      not hardly. Once every few weeks some cat is gonna up this shit..
Nov 19th 2012
128
           RE: not hardly. Once every few weeks some cat is gonna up this shit..
Nov 19th 2012
130
                RE: not hardly. Once every few weeks some cat is gonna up this shit..
Nov 19th 2012
131
                I'm as sure of this as I'm sure Brad Beal's missing a wide open jumper
Nov 19th 2012
132
RE: don't get scared now mf's!
Nov 19th 2012
126
This is an unfortunate agenda
Nov 19th 2012
129
wow, Barnes has been REALLY impressive. i'm almost sold on dude.
Nov 21st 2012
133
I'm definitely a Barnes convert
Nov 21st 2012
134
MGK been struggling like shit lately
Feb 02nd 2013
135
Not a single GM would take Barnes over MKG at this point
Feb 02nd 2013
136
ain't score >10 pts in like 3 weeks on a shitty team
Feb 02nd 2013
137
You see his guards?
Feb 02nd 2013
138
      I hate Jordan
Feb 02nd 2013
139
      Steph, Klay, and Jack take more shots per game, lmao
Feb 02nd 2013
140
barnes scored more tonight than mgk did last 4 games
Feb 03rd 2013
144
He's doing better than LaMarcus Aldridge as a rookie.
Feb 02nd 2013
141
      damn and we spent a platinum post arguing about two rookies?
Feb 02nd 2013
142
      That's Just Wrong
Feb 03rd 2013
155
damn i may have jinxed bol
Feb 02nd 2013
143
Barnes balled out tonight
Feb 03rd 2013
145
      u gotta stay up on top of your agendas bro
Feb 03rd 2013
146
           Let em know SPM
Feb 03rd 2013
147
           RE: Let em know SPM
Feb 03rd 2013
148
                LOL you are a PATHOLOGICAL liar
Feb 03rd 2013
158
           post been untouched because barnes a 9 and 4 nigga...
Feb 03rd 2013
149
                damn u resorting to this tactic after niggas stay using it on u? lmao
Feb 03rd 2013
150
                     when barnes got better stats, you holla back
Feb 03rd 2013
151
                          better than 6 and 2 or 9 and 5 on a shitty team
Feb 03rd 2013
152
                               nope...MKG 10 and 6.
Feb 03rd 2013
153
                                    LOL @ you championing 1+point and 1+ rebound
Feb 03rd 2013
159
                                         Is GS gonna win the title? No? Why do the wins matter then?
Feb 03rd 2013
161
                                              B/c NONE of your guys making the playoffs
Feb 03rd 2013
164
So this is getting upped everytime Barnes has a decent game?
Feb 03rd 2013
154
yup, clearly MKG is the better player
Feb 03rd 2013
156
what u keep coming in here for then?
Feb 03rd 2013
157
Honestly I don't even care about Barnes vs MKG
Feb 03rd 2013
160
Bitch, you mad I got people talkin about UNCs weak fuckin pros
Feb 03rd 2013
162
      LOL @ you tryin to sneak in during the SB
Feb 03rd 2013
163
      RE: LOL @ you tryin to sneak in during the SB
Feb 03rd 2013
166
           Ty Lawson got more wins in a week than Kyrie got this season
Feb 03rd 2013
167
      You got WEAK PLAYERS PERIOD!!!!!!!!!
Feb 03rd 2013
165
yep
Apr 24th 2013
169
gilly ballin...barnes platooning as usual
Mar 05th 2013
168
I just realized the Bobcats have more potential on their team
Apr 24th 2013
170
you think so?
Apr 24th 2013
171
Somewhat. Wondering aloud.
Apr 24th 2013
172
Watch 'em play Doc.
Apr 24th 2013
173
smh
Nov 27th 2013
174
Goddamn
Nov 28th 2013
175
damn, "Mini-KG" ain't broke double digits in 10 games
Dec 04th 2013
176
BillyOcean cryin in the car
Dec 04th 2013
177
Yeah, this has me REALLY concerned right now.
Dec 04th 2013
178
      both of MKG's hands are "non-shooting" hands, lol
Dec 04th 2013
185
           Yet shoots over 50%. Weird
Dec 04th 2013
186
                when u only get 5 or 6 shots a game that are mostly layups and putbacks....
Dec 05th 2013
188
                     Points are points. You're arguing your better shooting SF is scoring...
Dec 05th 2013
189
he broke his hand tho
Dec 04th 2013
180
a slightly more athletic George Lynch
Dec 04th 2013
182
      Word?
Dec 04th 2013
184
           A shorter Stromile Swift?
Dec 04th 2013
187
Smh
Dec 04th 2013
181
I'm changing my vote to yellow.
Dec 04th 2013
179
with 2 capital L's
Dec 04th 2013
183
      MKG is very young (just turned 20) and hurt in an awful franchise.
Dec 05th 2013
190
one of the two is being shopped for a trade right now:
Dec 18th 2013
191
Fresh off Harry's 8 and 4 game....He's on FIRE! (c)NBA Jam voice
Dec 18th 2013
192
don't matter. trying to dump a #2 overall pick a year and half into his
Dec 18th 2013
193
Not really. Leaving the Bobcats is far from a L.
Dec 18th 2013
194
      Nah, but having their draft talent evaluators think you're good is
Dec 18th 2013
195
           Yes, the Bobcats talent evaluators dropped the ball not their impressive...
Dec 18th 2013
197
lol cmon a highly-touted lottery pick in trade rumors?
Dec 18th 2013
196
      So they can have 8 and 4?
Dec 18th 2013
198
           RE: So they can have 8 and 4?
Dec 18th 2013
202
                he'd probably be their leading scorer
Dec 18th 2013
203
                Yes, because Barnes has proven he's an elite scorer.
Dec 18th 2013
205
                     kemba is the bobcats leading scoring at 17 per on 40% shooting
Dec 18th 2013
209
                          1.) He would have to get the ball from Kemba.
Dec 18th 2013
210
                Hmmm....interesting....if only there was something like a...I don't know...
Dec 18th 2013
204
oh, the one that wasn't supposed to be a franchise player?
Dec 18th 2013
199
      the one that was the #2 overall pick
Dec 18th 2013
200
           8 and 4
Dec 18th 2013
201
                you keep posting that and it does nothing for you
Dec 18th 2013
206
                     ***sigh*** A part from from being bullish with your ignorance
Dec 18th 2013
207
                     im here bc I wanted to see how those 2 guys generated a dbl plat post
Dec 18th 2013
211
                          MKG has to keep them honest with jumpshot.
Dec 18th 2013
213
                               but if he never develops a jumper, he won't be better than Barnes
Dec 18th 2013
216
                                    MKG is better than Barnes right now.
Dec 18th 2013
217
                                         Youre so mad and wrong its affecting your reading comp loo
Dec 18th 2013
218
                                              No you don't get it. Dumb dickheads who form there opinions...
Dec 18th 2013
219
                     supposed to be a STAR. i refuse to recalibrate for that dude
Dec 18th 2013
208
                          yeah I dont care about his high school expectations
Dec 18th 2013
212
                               Not when you consider the team.
Dec 18th 2013
214
                                    that should have said "rookie contract"...and yes thats a fair point
Dec 18th 2013
215
http://youtu.be/uBSrP7ub6VA
Dec 20th 2013
220
Moe Harkless >>> MKG
Dec 20th 2013
221
http://www.basketball-reference.com/players/h/harklma01.html
Dec 20th 2013
222
Kawhi > both of them
Dec 20th 2013
223
sucks barnes didn't get traded to a team where he could start
Feb 21st 2014
224
True, Barnes has been playing well this year. He needs a team...
Feb 21st 2014
225
RBO...get at these bammas
Oct 18th 2014
226
Oh, they really thought Barnes would capitalize off posting up...
Oct 18th 2014
227
      when i'm back on the 'cast, i'm bringing up Barnes v. Klay
Oct 18th 2014
228
this still a thing or nah?
Dec 16th 2014
229
barnes not a star...it will always be an L for anyone who cysed him
Dec 16th 2014
230
they're both kinda wack, Barnes is less wack though and his team is...
Dec 16th 2014
231
that and him glueing iggy to the bench @ $12 mil per
Dec 16th 2014
232
      Yeah I think Barnes would have better numbers if he was on a shitty...
Dec 16th 2014
233
Probably shouldn't be
Dec 16th 2014
234
Nah, MKG still better.
Dec 16th 2014
235
Barnes found a coach who can maximize his talent
Dec 16th 2014
236
      yup z.lowe broke this down recently
Dec 16th 2014
237
      maxmized his talent....that says it all. i agree.
Dec 17th 2014
239
we still on this?
May 27th 2015
240
Whole buncha idiots talking ZOMG PPG avg
May 27th 2015
241
      there's only one way to not be the superstar you were predicted to be
May 27th 2015
243
he was scoreless just a few days ago...he's harrison barnes.
May 27th 2015
242
"his best not better than MKG's best" - unluckily yours, MUSH, 11/2012
May 27th 2015
244
      i stand by it...congrats on your 3.5 star.
May 27th 2015
245
Lmao...so Harrison is good today?
May 27th 2015
246
He's been good all year.
May 27th 2015
247
      He's been solid. A piece. A replaceable piece.
May 27th 2015
248
           Like that's a bad thing
May 27th 2015
249
           MKG right now is still better than Harrison Barnes
May 28th 2015
252
                We'll see where MKG gets to
May 28th 2015
253
                is MKG a "star"? will he ever be a "star"?
May 28th 2015
260
                     75% chance he will be. 100% chance he's closer to one than Harry.
May 28th 2015
261
           He's consistently stepped up big when Curry/Klay have been off
May 27th 2015
250
                Probably the most consistent warrior all playoffs
May 28th 2015
255
                     the guy just went SCORELESS
May 28th 2015
259
                          And shut Harden schmoove the fuck down. In a game they won by 35
May 28th 2015
264
                               scoring is the only thing that matters to these cats
May 28th 2015
280
                                    Cats are just going to be obstinate no matter what
May 28th 2015
282
MKG can be the better player. Barnes can be the player w/ the ring.
May 27th 2015
251
One of these guys has worked VERY hard on their jumper
May 28th 2015
254
such a cyse. it was game 5, up 3-1, pulling away
May 28th 2015
256
      lmao Barnes the one that pulled it away.
May 28th 2015
257
           please...they were LEADING when he was in single digits.
May 28th 2015
258
                I read that as, he outperformed Klay in a WCF elimination game
May 28th 2015
265
                     the guy that scored 20 in 22 minutes and left the game?
May 28th 2015
267
Where those MKG playoff highlights at tho?
May 28th 2015
262
I see H. Barnes Goalpost Moving & Storage still doing brisk business.
May 28th 2015
263
Which means, he's winning.
May 28th 2015
266
Tho not a star or better player, Barnes has had a better career than MKG
May 28th 2015
268
      i'm sure he wishes his PG/SG were steph/klay, not kemba/lance
May 28th 2015
269
      So youre saying MKG needs to play w/ superstars in order to shine?
May 28th 2015
270
           i'm sayin he needs to play wit 'em to be a role player in the nba finals
May 28th 2015
271
           No, he's saying the only reason people remember Harrison is cuz..
May 28th 2015
273
                So MKG wont be remembered because of Kemba & Lance?
May 28th 2015
274
                     Nobody said that...lmao...this dumbass alias. Smh
May 28th 2015
276
                          In essence that is what youre saying
May 28th 2015
281
      Because of team success?
May 28th 2015
272
      Winning is the name of the game.
May 28th 2015
275
           #RingsMatter
May 28th 2015
277
                i'm so excited for a bad team to overpay barnes
May 28th 2015
278
                     Dubs resigning him this off-season. So much for that.
May 28th 2015
284
                     Who would pay him though?
May 28th 2015
289
      This year, MKG did everything better except jump shooting.
May 28th 2015
279
           If Barnes is Calbert Cheaney than who is MKG?
May 28th 2015
283
           Someone better.
May 28th 2015
286
                I'll help ya out. How about Draymond Green?
May 28th 2015
287
                     i said draymond was better than him years ago and laughter followed
May 28th 2015
288
                     MKG doesn't have Green's basketball IQ
May 28th 2015
291
                          You came to that conclusion from all of the Bobcats/Hornets you watch?
May 28th 2015
292
           MKG is a bamma, a hustle guy, that's all he'll ever be
May 28th 2015
285
Sidebar: I'm still sitting pretty on Tobias >>>>> Harrison too.
May 28th 2015
290
Once and for all can you stop with this irrelevant ass nigga?
Jun 09th 2015
293
Good uppage. MKG played better than Barnes did tonight.
Jun 09th 2015
294
Lol...Barnes needs Tyronne Lue on him to get going.
Jun 10th 2015
295
where is MKG right now?
Jun 10th 2015
296
At home, like all of the other players who aren't Warriors or Cavaliers
Jun 10th 2015
297
Stupid ass uppage
Jun 10th 2015
298
      As opposed to all the times this gets upped when he scores 18?
Jun 10th 2015
299
      11, 5, 1 on 44%, 32% from 3. 11.7 PER.
Jun 10th 2015
300
      Smh...I was willing to let this drop from existence in 2012.
Jun 10th 2015
301
      this his second scoreless game in two weeks, man
Jun 10th 2015
302
      The most bricking'est supposed knock down shooter ever.
Jun 10th 2015
303
           who called him a knockdown shooter? that's extremely liberal usage
Jun 10th 2015
305
      He was terrible and he deserved to be fried like the turkey he is
Jun 10th 2015
304
           GS is terrible and they deserve to be fried like the turkeys they are
Jun 10th 2015
306
                bruh time to get the fukk off dat licka
Jun 10th 2015
307
                     MKG >>> Dray (c) no one EVAH
Jun 10th 2015
308
                          Now Draymond is in this conversation? Dude STFU.
Jun 10th 2015
309
                          "They gotta do what they gotta do!" - Moesha
Jun 10th 2015
310
                          RE: MKG >>> Klay (c) no one EVAH
Jun 12th 2015
312
*moonwalks in this post*
Jun 10th 2015
311
It dont mean a thing if you aint got that ring!!
Jun 17th 2015
313

Lobby Okay Sports Okay Sports Archives topic #103191 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com