This is the kind of stuff that makes the board fun to debate on (and not just entertaining to syce) - to see really cogent arguments laid out. I've always had MJ as #1. I grew up in Illinois and watched his first 3-peat title run as a kid and he remains the most legendary player in the league as far as i'm concerned - and the most accomplished. The unblemished finals record is mayweather-like perfection that will be tough for anyone to topple.

LeBron is the next evolution of the GOAT prototype type player - and he's clearly #2 (or 2b alongside Kareem) already when you objectively look at his mix of team and individual accomplishments. But he's not done and can close the gap. After all - Jordan still won 3 titles after age 32/33 - so there is some time, but it would have to be an epic finish.

-->