Go back to previous topic
Forum nameOkay Sports
Topic subjectYeah...every GM after Isiah was worse for the Knicks
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=8&topic_id=2617205
2617205, Yeah...every GM after Isiah was worse for the Knicks
Posted by Basaglia, Sun Jul-09-17 07:22 PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nR71zrXRTmg

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TH5oUHUxqcs&t=293s

Phil really outdid himself.

And I don't expect Knick fans or media to talk about it. But, this is a fuckin debacle.
2617210, In phil's defense...
Posted by Cenario, Sun Jul-09-17 09:13 PM
2617212, Hard to argue that.
Posted by Ryan M, Sun Jul-09-17 09:53 PM
Melo, Amare, and Noah's contracts have hampered them worse than Curry, Houston, etc ever did.
2617213, he should have taken smith. absolute layup.
Posted by Basaglia, Sun Jul-09-17 09:54 PM
2617215, Houston's deal wasnt even that bad
Posted by cgonz00cc, Sun Jul-09-17 10:18 PM
he was a little overpaid, but he earned that deal for the most part

the disaster after he signed it was just shit ass luck
2617224, Houston?
Posted by Cenario, Mon Jul-10-17 06:11 AM
2617278, sure, except the Curry trade also cost them #2 pick in 2006 & #9 in 2007
Posted by 40thStreetBlack, Mon Jul-10-17 04:56 PM
which became Lamarcus and Noah, among other disasters.
2617296, Yeah as bad as phil was, he left us with zingis,draft picks and cap space
Posted by Cenario, Mon Jul-10-17 08:22 PM
But he was terrible and I'm glad he's gone.
2617214, could Dolan's idiocy also be classified as admirable loyalty?
Posted by ShawndmeSlanted, Sun Jul-09-17 09:58 PM
Word is griffin didnt take the job cause they wouldn't let him fire Houston and mills. Dolan still loves him some zeke, and seek would still be a knock if it wasn't for the meddling media
2617225, That s been one of dolan faults for the longest time
Posted by Cenario, Mon Jul-10-17 06:12 AM
2617266, I'd love to know
Posted by Numba_33, Mon Jul-10-17 02:47 PM
if it was strictly up to Mills to make things hard for Griffin or if Dolan gave him orders to keep things pretty much the same in terms of personnel.

Either way, I don't see a big name front office person wanting to take that job since they'd be handcuffed by the current regime, in addition to how dismal to present looks for the team.
2617229, Agreed wholeheartedly!
Posted by Creole, Mon Jul-10-17 08:13 AM
2617250, started with Scott Layden imo
Posted by jrocc, Mon Jul-10-17 11:52 AM
he was right before Isaiah and was the absolute worst. they used to call him Bin Layden he was so bad.

http://www.basketball-reference.com/executives/laydesc99x.html
2617267, Among the front office folks somewhat recently hired
Posted by Numba_33, Mon Jul-10-17 02:50 PM
Phil had the closest to a clean slate to start out with, correct? Or did he come to the Knicks around the time of that terrible Bargarni trade? That's in addition to the fact Dolan completely steered clear of Phil outside of when he wanted to boot Porzingis out of NYC.

And no, I don't care enough about the dude to look up the correct spelling of his name.
2617269, Water is wet, yet I enjoy seeing hyped Knickas suffer so I'm here for it all
Posted by mtbatol, Mon Jul-10-17 03:20 PM
2617302, I mean it's a low bar but I think point I think we can stop blaming GMs
Posted by ConcreteCharlie, Mon Jul-10-17 09:22 PM
Everyone who has held control there since Grunfeld (who is no prize but Jesus, by comparison, sure) has been awful. Not only GMs but also Larry Brown, who had considerable control when he was coaching. Thomas was an OK GM in his other two stints, obviously Brown and Jackson were successful in other places/roles, etc. Just a sick culture there, really hard to think of many that match it in pro sports. I guess the Redskins come to mind.
2617311, I think alot of it comes down to control....doLan gonna hold on
Posted by Cenario, Mon Jul-10-17 10:24 PM
To what he gonna hold on to, and alot of these other dudes think they gonna get what they want, and they dont.

And Phil's success in other places is irrelevant.

Dolan is awful, and alot of these dudes been awful while they were here bc of their own poor decisions
2617336, yeah but some reasons are shared, others aren't
Posted by ConcreteCharlie, Tue Jul-11-17 09:53 AM
the common thread is being pressed, throwing money at the problem and acquiring names rather than talent.
2617368, And the name dolan acquired was feel
Posted by Cenario, Tue Jul-11-17 01:03 PM
And he was terrible at his job.

Not sure what we disagreeing about?
2617310, We been talked about it. Go jinx Cleveland or Chicago, yo.
Posted by Castro, Mon Jul-10-17 10:19 PM
2617323, ^^^^^this your problem right here. everything a "jinx"
Posted by Basaglia, Tue Jul-11-17 08:22 AM

meanwhile, knick fans been defending the hardaway deal like it's defensible.
2617331, Are they really?
Posted by Cenario, Tue Jul-11-17 09:07 AM
2617335, yes. knicks twitter is.
Posted by Basaglia, Tue Jul-11-17 09:50 AM
2617353, Ok have to take your word for it
Posted by Cenario, Tue Jul-11-17 11:04 AM
2617338, lol
Posted by ConcreteCharlie, Tue Jul-11-17 09:55 AM
yeah my buddy is an old-time knicks fan and he asked what i thought of the deal. i kind of gave a pregnant pause and he was like "yeah, fuck, i know."

good for hardaway though, that's that generational wealth.
2617351, A defense of the Hardaway deal:
Posted by Castro, Tue Jul-11-17 10:57 AM
1. Youngster comes into the league, 2nd generation...Pops is a legit HOFer but the brand has been tarnished because Pops is whitelisted.

2. Youngster ends up in the biggest market with the supposed GOAT running the organization and his handpicked guy running the team.

3. Youngster performs ooookay at best in a chaotic situation,little or no development of his game/mentoring forthcoming because his coach is fucking his girlfriend.

4. Young dude leaves town, goes to another city, game develops a bit, but more importantly for him, he is away from that toxic situation.

5. Toxic coach and fake GOAT both gone...organization re-signs Youngster....


Now all that said, Tim Hardaway is no savior....I am not going to sit here and give some hamfisted "look at his Per48!!!" bullshit. I am also not going to sit and say 'They had to do it'. They didn't have to do shit- they probably could luck up on someone from the development league or the summer league who could jack up shots and be a bamma. But dude got fucked over by his coach in NY and they brought him back for a fresh start.

What this move does is establish the beginnings of some professionalism from the front office that has had none since PJax decided he wanted to go back to Idaho of wherever the fuck he fishes. And professionalism means having some kind of fucking integrity about the environment you create for your players. This is a signal to Melo, Yung Kris and whomever else that has been stuck in this shit, that they are not going to treat them like Oakley got treated in MSG. It gives Hornacek, a legit coach, a chance to have a chance in his locker room.

Hardaway could end up being a Lance Thomas...or he could end up being a Spree. Who knows, but he plays like he cares about winning (which admittedly is not the same as knowing how...).




2617354, Seeeggggaaaaaa
Posted by Cenario, Tue Jul-11-17 11:08 AM
Bc i haven't seen good spin like this since Sonic the Hedgehog
2617360, What the fuck is there to spin?
Posted by Castro, Tue Jul-11-17 11:55 AM
From a finances, "GM" type perspective, its dumb. From a locker room perspective, its a start at rebuilding some trust.

Its not putting anyone in the seats. Its not going to get us in the playoffs. Where the fuck is the spin? To me it reads like someone (probably Mills) understands that money really don't matter for Dolan, so he isn't going to raise an eyebrow at a deal no other team would make...so he did it so he could have a legitimate conversation with Porzingis, who the Knicks actually want to build around, and with Melo, who the Knicks want to trade so they can start putting some pieces together.


There is no spin in that yo. Stop watching Fox.
2617365, Rebuilding trust with who?
Posted by Cenario, Tue Jul-11-17 12:49 PM
Only person on the team when fish was allegedly messing with THJ girl is Melo, which they want to trade anyway.

I think zingis would be more impressed with the Knicks spending their money wisely or having an actual plan that might lead to wins
2617359, Ray Clay voice: Seaaaaaaan, Spiiiiiiiiiiicerrrrrrrrr!
Posted by ConcreteCharlie, Tue Jul-11-17 11:55 AM
2617364, Cleveland has a built-in jinx: Dan Gilbert
Posted by Dr Claw, Tue Jul-11-17 12:42 PM