butler is a better defender and i think either of them will know their role playing with lebron. i think in a reduced role their scoring will be pretty similar, though PG is a better shooter. we don;'t know exactly what they are giving up so hard to say what they will need here.

the biggest thing is that butler is under contract for two years and george is only under contract for one. obviously that makes butler much more attractive, unless the price is significantly lower for george.