Based on individual talent, he's an all time great and probably deserves to be on the basketball Mouth Rushmore. I say probably because I never saw players before the 90's, so I can't say with conviction if LeBron is better or worse than Wilt/Kareem/other way before my time. However, he doesn't have the hardware YET to match up with the all time greats that are always brought up.

Since his career is not set in stone yet, its hard to crucify him for not matching or passing other all times great at this point in time.