So, are you telling me that you have to throw for a zillion yards in order to be a good qb? Games don't always end with high stat numbers. He put his team in a situation to win. Sometimes, QBs have their off games and other times they have their on games. But, when it comes down to brass tax, what matters most is Ws. That is what he is doing. Right now, he is in the upper echelon of QBs which is subject to change. Some people are way too much into statistics.