... may not be who he says he is? As in... he's working for Gabriel and them to recruit Paige, since they don't trust Phillip and Liz to do it?

There's just no way Pastor Tim goes public, and I'd be really put off if they made him into the usual one-note molester. What could he possibly do? And if his choice is to tell Phillip and Liz, what would they do about Tim? And Paige?

Terrific finale. Terrific season. Terrific show.