Go back to previous topic
Forum namePass The Popcorn
Topic subjectso should the top chef be only judged on THAT one meal?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=378081&mesg_id=378392
378392, so should the top chef be only judged on THAT one meal?
Posted by gusto, Thu Jun-12-08 11:02 PM
>Did Lisa really do the best but they held her resume against
>her? (which of course they're not supposed to do), or did they
>simply edit it to give her more of a chance? Looked like her
>red meat wasn't that great, but they didn't discuss it much at
>all. Meanwhile, the judges made cases for Lisa's other 3
>dishes as the best.

i can see ppl being eliminated based ONE MEAL/challenge. but to name top chef based on one meal is kinda wack. its not like steph cooked a wack meal. but all 3 were prolly good. and steph and lisa were prolly neck and neck, but the tiebreaker will no doubt go to steph.