Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectRE: is it really though? I'm a huge fan of both, but
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2802128&mesg_id=2803436
2803436, RE: is it really though? I'm a huge fan of both, but
Posted by philpot, Tue May-07-13 06:51 PM
>while
>many on here for some reason hate the very artists that
>brought us to the site (Com, Mos, Kwe, etc)

well, first, it's not hate...a lotta time has passed in lives & careers...personally i don't enjoy talib kweli music like i once did...AND THAT'S OK bc im actually NOT upset at what he does bc its HIS ART & he can & should do what he feels...that said i dont have to forcefeed myself the art bc i lived blackstar, RE & Quality...

>Anyway
>
>Is Mos' catelog really better? Or even to meet you half way,
>is it so much better its not even close?



>Because, off the top-
>
>1. Train of Thought
>2. Ecstatic
>3. Blackstar
>4. BOBS
>5. Quality
>6. Liberation
>7. Eardrum
>8. New Danger
>9. Beautiful Struggle (this would be a lot higher had they
>trimmed the fat and kept that Killer Mike track)
>10. Write About Now
>11. RPM
>
>

mos' catalog is better to me bc hes consistentw/ his sound & what hes tryna do...apart from RE, Liberation & Quality (& the beautiful mixtape) i dont see any compelling statements from talib, he makes albums full of songs, not albums in the sense of cohesive projects & WHEN HE DOES notice that there's typically a sidekick involved (Madlib, Mos, HITek, Kanye to an extent on Quality)

>
>
>12. True Magic
>

you dont know how i feel about this widely mocked & dismissed album...

>13. Gutter Rainbows
>
>
>Maybe its about even, but I definitely don't think its a clear
>Mos Def victory. And I'm a stan of dude.
>
>I feel like I'm forgetting one or two releases. I was also
>going to cheat and include that fist Beautiful Struggle
>mixtape that had some joints on it, but I won't.

loved that mixtape, played it tons

>I really do think that many people need to drop their grudge
>of Kweli. So he's a pr!ck online? Aren't most of us??
>

its not a grudge fam, i dont know the dude, but in interviews, online AND IN HIS RHYMES he comes across typically as smug, overly critical & dismissive of others and a fence rider not willing to commit to what he professes in his raps...also, he seems like a very smart dude & i feel he genuinely loves his people

>
>