Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectNothing Dilla did with an MPC has opened doors for anyone.
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2302013&mesg_id=2640120
2640120, Nothing Dilla did with an MPC has opened doors for anyone.
Posted by BarTek, Fri Dec-16-11 10:01 AM
>>Let Dilla be Dilla doggie. Hendrix's technical ability is
>far
>>greater than rearranging an already composed piece of music.
>
>Hendrix kicked open the doors of what people could/would do
>with a guitar. If you can't see a parallel of what Dilla (or
>other innovators) did with a more contemporary style of
>music-making, then think a little harder.
>

What Hendrix accomplished with the guitar is not even remotely comparable to what Dilla did with an mpc. How many Dilla clones are there out there today?

Many.

How many Hendrix clones?

None.

He can't be imitated.

Dilla presented a style that almost anyone with good practice can copy. You guys just don't get it and are reaching way too hard. Not everyone has to reflective of someone from another era. Why is this so important for you? Hendrix was also international and Dilla was underground. Why do you persist in this idiotic comparison? Furthermore, Hendrix was a real songwriter.. Dilla was a beat maker. How many other points do you need to hear about to realize that you're dead wrong? I love Dilla too but this is insulting to both artists.


>>Hendrix fused blues
>>with jazz and wrote technically sophisticated song
>structures
>>which he performed uniquely every time he performed, he was
>>notorious for never playing the same song twice, meaning,
>>every performance yielded a new outcome even though it was
>the
>>same song because he would improvise so much on the spot,
>>based on how he felt, what he experienced. There was nothing
>>"Arranged" or "Rehearsed" about his sound.. he was a wild
>man
>>with a guitar that was literally on fire. Dilla had some
>dope
>>drum patterns and he knew how to work a chop but you're
>>fucking crazy if you think he was on Hendrix level. Dilla
>>prolly rolled over in his grave after he heard this post
>form
>>the dead horse.
>
>You're comparing live performance to recording. What a
>waste...

Exactly why this is even a stupider shockier comparison. Dilla recorded, meaning.. he has unlimited takes to get it right. Hendrix performed it live and did it in a way that people still get wet dreams about.