Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectWhich TV show repped your city best? Treme, Wire, Sopranos
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13225344
13225344, Which TV show repped your city best? Treme, Wire, Sopranos
Posted by Firecracker, Fri Jan-12-18 04:00 AM

Only been to New Orleans once (a couple of days before Katrina), but how well / accurately does Treme depict NOLA?

I never really went to NJ like that, I feel like the Jersey you see on Sopranos is only representative of a very small corner of Jersey - it does it well, though. Right?

Of all the TV shows ever with a theme of A city, in your opinion - having watched and lived / stayed in said city, what series did the most believable and accurate portrayal of your town?

13225356, Word is the Wire was originally going to be in Philly....
Posted by KnowOne, Fri Jan-12-18 08:34 AM
but our sucka mayor was concerned about how the show would reflect on the city. I always wonder if it had been how accurately it would have repped the 215.
13225368, Wow I didn't know that
Posted by ThaTruth, Fri Jan-12-18 09:21 AM
13225406, That doesn't make any sense at all.
Posted by Cam, Fri Jan-12-18 10:47 AM
The creators, who also made Homicide & The Corner, of The Wire made the series in relation to those two story arcs.

Further, State Property was shot in Philly in '01, why would John Street say yes to making of that and no to The Wire. Also, that's not how Greater Philadelphia Film Office works.
13225407, That doesn't make any sense based on DS life, work and
Posted by dba_BAD, Fri Jan-12-18 10:47 AM
all the source material for the show

sorry but im pretty confident thats not true
13225442, your prob right.....
Posted by KnowOne, Fri Jan-12-18 11:53 AM
Im googling but cant find anything. Could of swore I read that in an interview some where. Maybe I'm mistaken.
13225658, RE: Word is the Wire was originally going to be in Philly....
Posted by Jay Doz, Sat Jan-13-18 02:41 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qqS1Ty79mOE
13225659, Not exactly how that story goes
Posted by Bumaye, Sat Jan-13-18 02:41 PM
My understanding is that some folks in Baltimore and Maryland started feeling uncomfortable with the depiction of the city after the first season, and then The Wire threatened to move production to Philly, cuz the cities look similar enough to have Philly stand in as Baltimore. So it was a threat to Baltimore and Maryland big wigs ("we'll just move production to Philly and CALL it Baltimore"). Bigwigs stopped complaining.
13225675, I was under the impression it was based on the corner
Posted by josephmurf2384, Sat Jan-13-18 06:11 PM
Which is about Baltimore. Was it supposed to be shot in Philly or was it going to be a different story?
13225357, Law and Order
Posted by Cenario, Fri Jan-12-18 08:44 AM
13225363, This Is Us, Friday Night Tykes Steel Country
Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Jan-12-18 09:06 AM
I had a long list of movies.

Silence of the Lambs prolly reps the city best cause it’s gray as shit.
13225364, Hairspray
Posted by ambient1, Fri Jan-12-18 09:10 AM
kidding

The Corner was spot on for that era

13225376, Dark times...sadly, still dark.
Posted by Overqualified, Fri Jan-12-18 09:45 AM
I've always toyed with the ideas of writing a 90s flip of growing up in Baltimore - sort of a Wonder Years type thing. A very unique time. I need to get back to it.
13225384, Yezzir...Very Unique time...that actually sounds like a dope
Posted by ambient1, Fri Jan-12-18 10:06 AM
premise

we gotta link man...I know I been missing in action/slacking

but yeah I really like this idea
13225366, Atlanta IS Atlanta
Posted by bigkarma, Fri Jan-12-18 09:18 AM
That show is dead on. Me and my buddies end up talking about the show the next day and comparing whatever the episode was about to our own stories.
13225372, RE: Atlanta IS Atlanta
Posted by JFrost1117, Fri Jan-12-18 09:39 AM
I think that shit is specially handcrafted to make anyone that’s lived here for more than a month stand up in their living room like “EXACTLY!!!”
13225985, It really is, I only lived there for a year and change
Posted by J_Stew, Mon Jan-15-18 03:04 PM
but so much of it feels like an inside joke, amazing job by them.
13225429, Probably THE answer, right? Atlanta for sure
Posted by Firecracker, Fri Jan-12-18 11:28 AM
>That show is dead on. Me and my buddies end up talking about
>the show the next day and comparing whatever the episode was
>about to our own stories.
13225410, I've seen a fair number of scenes set in Philly that were filmed elsewhere
Posted by flipnile, Fri Jan-12-18 10:55 AM
World War Z and Empire come to mind (also, Empire's 'NYC' obviously isn't).

Kinda the reverse of your question, because those films straight mis-represent.
13225469, I'll never forget the first time I say Sunny In Philly
Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Jan-12-18 12:42 PM
I lived in Center City at the time and was like "yo, I was just playing at that court the other day. I had no expectations but that shit had me rolling.

13225720, That show was fire in its prime
Posted by makaveli, Sun Jan-14-18 09:36 AM
.
13225719, that terrrible mob movie 10th and Wolf was filmed in Pittsburgh
Posted by makaveli, Sun Jan-14-18 09:34 AM
They could have made a good movie out of that story, I don’t know how they were able to make that movie so bad.
13225418, Veep
Posted by Walleye, Fri Jan-12-18 11:09 AM
Lots of cities are stuffed with venal dipshits, but only in DC do they think you should congratulate them for the higher calling of working for (or worse, not for but just in proximity-to) the federal government.

13225635, My DC vote is 227
Posted by Call It Anything, Sat Jan-13-18 02:48 AM
Almost by default. It's on a very short list for apolitical scripted show set in Washington DC. Others that come to mind were The District and That's My Mama. As somebody who grew up in an apolitical family in and around DC, I appreciate that somebody else saw the value in making a show like that. I appreciate DC Cab for the same reasons.
13225655, affirmative.
Posted by kinetic94761180, Sat Jan-13-18 02:22 PM
13225430, How on point is Treme though? Any opinion on that?
Posted by Firecracker, Fri Jan-12-18 11:29 AM

Took me a while to get into the show, but I'm almost done with the 1st season and I love it
13225450, New York Undercover
Posted by T Reynolds, Fri Jan-12-18 12:13 PM
lol

Nah i lived briefly as a baby in NYC in the 80's and then came back in 99, so i missed the golden era. but watching old ny undercover is beautiful man. Shots of the abandoned railroad tracks that is now 'The Highline', and an arcade in Times Square, some classic stuff.

I'm trying to remember some good LA ones.

13225455, L.A.: Insecure, South Central, Girlfriends
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Fri Jan-12-18 12:21 PM
All in different ways.

Insecure - The late 20's, early 30's, professional, and shows the L.A. native "kinda, but not really hood" lifestyle more than anything we've seen

South Central - Very very short lived, and dark as hell, but it definitely felt like how South Central did at the time.

Girlfriends - Basically what Insecure would be if the characters were transplanted and more successful, and it def represented that time period. The neighborhood was that Mid Wilshire, Miracle Mile side, and that side is never really shown on TV because it's literally and figuratively "below Hollywood, and above the hood" location and economics wise.

And that's just me mentioning Black shows and the Black lifestyle. I wouldn't mention "Entourage" because that's like 0.5% of the population who's able to really live like that...but I've for sure had nights that resembled what they experienced.
13225476, Just found South Central on YouTube
Posted by Firecracker, Fri Jan-12-18 12:56 PM

8 eps or so, binged em the other day

13225629, I agree w/ all three
Posted by ramaj1, Sat Jan-13-18 01:27 AM
I'd argue that Girlfriends reps some of the "higher end" of Leimert, maybe the View Park side of things.
13225661, Insecure be making me nostalgic for shit that’s right down the street.
Posted by IkeMoses, Sat Jan-13-18 03:33 PM
13225466, Baskets is bullcrap
Posted by Wonderl33t, Fri Jan-12-18 12:39 PM
it's supposed to be Bakersfield. It's not filmed here and the stereotypes are awful.
______________________________
http://i.imgur.com/v2ye7l2.jpg
13225468, Not for nothing, I never hit the Costco for lunch until that show.
Posted by Cam, Fri Jan-12-18 12:42 PM
That show's hilarious.
13225638, No great options...Nebraska and Election
Posted by Nodima, Sat Jan-13-18 08:36 AM
The problem with Nebraska, for me, is that it captures my state but not my town. Omaha is amazingly different from the rest of the state, including Lincoln. But Nebraska very much captures what this state is.

Election, I see a lot of people like those people and have memories of those sorts of teenagers when I was in school, but that’s not necessarily a man “Omaha” movie despite being set here. That said, considering the growth and change this city has experienced in the past 20 years, a lot of those location shots are incredible to see as a local now.

I will say that I’ve heard more than one person from out of town that’s visited, and is black, tell me they felt Snow on tha Bluff could’ve been filmed here and not lost much of its economic vibe. So there’s that. I haven’t met many non white, non local people that have anything nice to say about this city.

~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." � Jay Bilas
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
13225662, The accent work on Snowfall is incredible. WC a great coach.
Posted by IkeMoses, Sat Jan-13-18 03:34 PM
13225677, He really is.
Posted by JFrost1117, Sat Jan-13-18 06:28 PM
I rarely watch "Making Of"'s anymore, but seeing WC was involved was cool.
13225993, However, RZA in **NO** way sounds like he's from Oakland
Posted by mrhood75, Mon Jan-15-18 03:24 PM
13225980, EMPIRE!!! Reppin' The Chi!!!....n/m
Posted by Brownsugar, Mon Jan-15-18 02:53 PM


♥ :* I LUV U 2!!! :* ♥
13225989, Roger & me
Posted by shygurl, Mon Jan-15-18 03:08 PM
There are issues of course, but it does capture that rust belt decline pretty well.
13226000, Portlandia has to be up there, right?
Posted by J_Stew, Mon Jan-15-18 03:32 PM
I'm from Austin and I felt like a lot of that applied to us too.
13226003, The Fish that Saved Pittsburgh
Posted by legsdiamond, Mon Jan-15-18 03:36 PM
13226229, Sopranos is spot on for North Jersey.
Posted by bski, Tue Jan-16-18 12:29 PM
Not from there but used to live on the border of NY and NJ.