Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectEminem - Walk On Water ft. Beyoncé
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13211824
13211824, Eminem - Walk On Water ft. Beyoncé
Posted by bwood, Sun Nov-12-17 10:24 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1WpP7iowLc

First single off of Revival. Produced by Rick Rubin.
13211826, dis is gahbige.
Posted by tariqhu, Sun Nov-12-17 10:30 AM
I'm a fan of dude, but I can't with the track.
13211829, Odd choice for a first single
Posted by Adwhizz, Sun Nov-12-17 10:48 AM
can't really see this getting much radio play

LOL @ The last 5 seconds, that came WAY out of left field
13211836, might as well have been a macklemore song.
Posted by Reeq, Sun Nov-12-17 11:17 AM
and he needs to stop fucking with rick rubin.
13211838, ^^^ Sees IT! ^^^
Posted by bibblegolf, Sun Nov-12-17 11:31 AM
13211855, RE: Eminem - Walk On Water ft. Beyoncé
Posted by double 0, Sun Nov-12-17 01:33 PM
I fucked with it..

RAPS
13211856, There must be something else he can do.
Posted by SoWhat, Sun Nov-12-17 01:37 PM
13211859, Sounds like anyone could have produced this
Posted by Sofian_Hadi, Sun Nov-12-17 01:39 PM
13211860, I'm actually embarrassed for him. This is awful.
Posted by kwez, Sun Nov-12-17 01:43 PM

************************
13211868, This stinks but it will probably be really popular
Posted by makaveli, Sun Nov-12-17 02:36 PM
13211872, He needs to follow Hurricane G's advice
Posted by BigReg, Sun Nov-12-17 02:58 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBNh2PPqlJs&t=0m33s

Just cause its supposed to be serious doesn't mean its gotta be boring.
13211876, Eminem has ALWAYS been trash
Posted by Anonymous, Sun Nov-12-17 03:58 PM
This just continues the story
13211878, yeah, I can count on one hand the number of Eminem songs I like
Posted by DJR, Sun Nov-12-17 04:11 PM
13211881, For real
Posted by Anonymous, Sun Nov-12-17 05:37 PM
13211884, FOH you buggin'
Posted by Somnus, Sun Nov-12-17 06:05 PM
13212124, Most of his songs suck IMO
Posted by legsdiamond, Mon Nov-13-17 11:20 AM
but he isn’t making these for the Hip Hop crowd
13212436, #30 & might I add "Evil Deeds" & "Rabbit Run" <-- one of the best...
Posted by Somnus, Tue Nov-14-17 09:53 AM
run-on verses EVER!

plus a myriad of legendary mixtape appearances

Em's earned his place amongst the greats

it's undeniable.
13212440, dude is a beast on mixtapes and guest spots
Posted by legsdiamond, Tue Nov-14-17 09:58 AM
but he is hot gahhhhbage as a solo artist when it comes to album cuts. Sooo much filler with only 4 or 5 bangers.

IMO the production on his albums is also terrible.
13212442, yeah production has always been his Achilles heel, especially when
Posted by Somnus, Tue Nov-14-17 10:11 AM
he takes the helm (see: God's Son's "The Cross"...smdh)

he just ain't got an ear, like say a Game or (ugh hate to even mention him) Rick Ross

BUT

the MMLP is, was & will always be a masterpiece, production wise included.
13212390, that's a gross exaggeration lol
Posted by Damali, Tue Nov-14-17 12:35 AM
Forgot About Dre
Guilty Conscience
The Real Slim Shady
Renegade
Rap God
Lose Yourself
13212430, Haha of course it is, but you could've provided some better examples.
Posted by Brew, Tue Nov-14-17 09:43 AM
If I Get Locked Up Tonight
Any Man
Role Model
Just Don't Give a Fuck
I'm Shady
Stan
Who Knew
I'm Back
Criminal
Square Dance
Say Goodbye to Hollywood
Deja Vu

Etc.
13212433, If I Get Locked Up Tonight was my jam
Posted by makaveli, Tue Nov-14-17 09:47 AM
he crushes that song.
13212438, Yea he does. That's quintessential Eminem stuff.
Posted by Brew, Tue Nov-14-17 09:54 AM
Just rhyming his ass off, spitting ridiculous/funny stuff but nothing *too* shock value/forced.

That song is him at his best IMO.
13212439, I should add "Love Me" and "We All Die One Day"
Posted by Brew, Tue Nov-14-17 09:56 AM
Insane verses on both.
13212441, pretty much
Posted by ambient1, Tue Nov-14-17 10:08 AM
13211880, shit
Posted by BrooklynWHAT, Sun Nov-12-17 05:32 PM
13211885, str8 doodoo water. wtf was he thinking?
Posted by Somnus, Sun Nov-12-17 06:07 PM
13212415, damn, jinx lol
Posted by MiracleRic, Tue Nov-14-17 09:00 AM
13212437, haha great minds, my friend, great minds.
Posted by Somnus, Tue Nov-14-17 09:54 AM
13211889, I legit played this with an open mind, but...
Posted by Dstl1, Sun Nov-12-17 06:22 PM
the shit is embarrassingly bad.
13211904, Awkward irony
Posted by sectachrome86, Sun Nov-12-17 07:25 PM
He's rapping about how he isn't perfect and struggles with making a good song now

on a garbage song

https://youtu.be/n1WpP7iowLc?t=1m37s

BITCH I WROTE STAN!

And not a fucking thing since!
13212116, This is another "Love the way you lie" so it will do good
Posted by soken, Mon Nov-13-17 11:01 AM
I have no idea why but I guess Eminem's pop route is working out well for him.
13212118, His audience loves it.
Posted by Innocent Criminal, Mon Nov-13-17 11:08 AM
ie, white people that listen to rock radio.
13212129, and it will chart for those stations
Posted by The3rdOne, Mon Nov-13-17 11:40 AM
that claim they don't play hip-hop
13212383, I don't get this shit, but it'll work for both of them, somehow.
Posted by Nodima, Mon Nov-13-17 11:53 PM
Easy to forget Eminem is 45-years old while walking around in the world thinking about Eminem as often as I do anymore, but "Walk on Water" is a great reminder of his age. If Jay-Z found a way to make 47 sound cool earlier this year, Eminem found a way to make 45 sound boring as hell. "Walk on Water" is mostly the sound of a man complaining about how talented he is, how famous he was, and how technically sound and financially successful his post-rehab material is because, and he's right, anybody with a platform is quick to point out how boring it all is to listen to. So here he gets Beyoncé to sing a completely pointless, exhausting hook that Eminem would never sound appropriate next to anyway and then asks Rick Rubin to make one of the least inspired tributes to the most boring aspects of artists like Carole King.

The experience of listening to this song for the first time is about as perplexing as it possibly could be, and none of it feels particularly revelatory or exciting. Eminem works in a very strange space - after this song finished, Youtube moved to a video with 160,000,000+ views called "Guts Over Fear" that Eminem apparently created in 2014 with Sia. I'd never heard of it before. Eminem learned with "Fack" and Encore that there are a lot of people out in the world who've made up their minds on Eminem in the following way: he's perfect and there's not another rapper out there worth listening to as feverishly. So here's a song that doesn't really seem like it's for those people, or the BET Cypher people, or his old fans, or his new fans, or Beyoncé fans, or Rick Rubin fans, or fans of music in general.

It'll probably be a huge success.


~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." � Jay Bilas
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
13212432, LOL this is the perfect description/post because ...
Posted by Brew, Tue Nov-14-17 09:47 AM
... it comes to no conclusion, just like the song it describes has no point.

You're right. It's so weird. He's pandering to everybody, but pandering to nobody. I listen to his old tracks and there's rhythm, and flow, and cadence, on top of the lyricism.

He hasn't exhibited any ability to create music with some feeling and soul since 2009. It's unfortunate considering his immeasurable talent.


>Easy to forget Eminem is 45-years old while walking around in
>the world thinking about Eminem as often as I do anymore, but
>"Walk on Water" is a great reminder of his age. If Jay-Z found
>a way to make 47 sound cool earlier this year, Eminem found a
>way to make 45 sound boring as hell. "Walk on Water" is mostly
>the sound of a man complaining about how talented he is, how
>famous he was, and how technically sound and financially
>successful his post-rehab material is because, and he's right,
>anybody with a platform is quick to point out how boring it
>all is to listen to. So here he gets Beyoncé to sing a
>completely pointless, exhausting hook that Eminem would never
>sound appropriate next to anyway and then asks Rick Rubin to
>make one of the least inspired tributes to the most boring
>aspects of artists like Carole King.
>
>The experience of listening to this song for the first time is
>about as perplexing as it possibly could be, and none of it
>feels particularly revelatory or exciting. Eminem works in a
>very strange space - after this song finished, Youtube moved
>to a video with 160,000,000+ views called "Guts Over Fear"
>that Eminem apparently created in 2014 with Sia. I'd never
>heard of it before. Eminem learned with "Fack" and Encore that
>there are a lot of people out in the world who've made up
>their minds on Eminem in the following way: he's perfect and
>there's not another rapper out there worth listening to as
>feverishly. So here's a song that doesn't really seem like
>it's for those people, or the BET Cypher people, or his old
>fans, or his new fans, or Beyoncé fans, or Rick Rubin fans,
>or fans of music in general.
>
>It'll probably be a huge success.
>
>
>~~~~~~~~~
>"This is the streets, and I am the trap." � Jay Bilas
>http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
>Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
13212386, This shit ain't for me (c) DJ Akademiks
Posted by Kira, Tue Nov-14-17 12:08 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-PruE_yT7w&t=530s

Em's been washed for a minute now but gets the pass because he's so technical and is great at what he does. It sucks that he wasted a Beyonce chorus but he's sold enough records to justify the collaboration.

His music is good as bar for younger emcees to measure up to. This song is basura straight ass. I had to cleanse my ears of this filth by listening to some 6lack:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5p6VBfWHKU
13212389, what the hell?
Posted by Damali, Tue Nov-14-17 12:30 AM
i actually feel bad for him...damn.
13212414, dookie water
Posted by MiracleRic, Tue Nov-14-17 08:59 AM
13212416, lol
Posted by legsdiamond, Tue Nov-14-17 09:04 AM
13212443, Just gonna assume it's wack off the song title and feature
Posted by flipnile, Tue Nov-14-17 10:13 AM
13212529, my dry heave this morning over the toilet sounded better
Posted by Amritsar, Tue Nov-14-17 12:18 PM
This dude has way more terrible songs than good ones



wayyyyy more
13212530, Throw the whole song away
Posted by Tw3nty, Tue Nov-14-17 12:19 PM
Nigga just reading from his diary now.