>..yet, we have.
>
>and it failed. not because its impossible, but because people
>aren't always respectful/responsible adults.

Give a designated second person mod powers over that one post and let them keep folks in line. Give them a CW badge or whatever.

>if you're gonna be upset about it, take your peers to task.

In case you haven't noticed I've actually done that plenty. At any rate I'm simply having a conversation with you and posing ideas. I can't possibly know every idea you've ever tried so no, I didn't say it as though you haven't tried it.

Frankly you're coming across more contentious and upset over the discussion than I am.