Go back to previous topic
Forum nameGeneral Discussion
Topic subjectBlack amateur stand up comedy is the worst.
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=12704096
12704096, Black amateur stand up comedy is the worst.
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 11:21 AM
Last night a friend performed at one of the big comedy clubs out here.
Dope except for it was black night

My friend did well, before she went on not one but TWO different dudes had a routine that went:

"Yesterday was MLK Day, how many a yall seen Selma?", both with jokes about what Instagram and trending topics would have been like back then

the absolute worst.

not to mention, I guess any sentence with "niggas" or "bitches" is supposed to make me laugh because Im black and the comedian is black

edit to add: I respect the bravery that it even takes to get up there and attempt entertaining an audience but please try better
12704100, You are about to get called a Coon.
Posted by Case_One, Wed Jan-21-15 11:23 AM
You better watch how you talk about Black people.


.
.
.
"Today is your day to have a better life -- it's your right."
12704105, you hate black people. we get it.
Posted by Deadzombie, Wed Jan-21-15 11:26 AM
12704110, omg please die. thank you
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 11:27 AM
12704123, bad show. me dying wont make you less embarrassed of your skin.
Posted by Deadzombie, Wed Jan-21-15 11:32 AM
i thought you were working on your nonsensical-negativity.

what happened with that?
12704150, I will work on my issues with black people. you work on dying
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 11:45 AM
12704156, i plan to live forever. so far so good.
Posted by Deadzombie, Wed Jan-21-15 11:48 AM
12704229, this explains a lot...lol
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Jan-21-15 12:38 PM
12704290, i was here for this exchange
Posted by astralblak, Wed Jan-21-15 01:03 PM
.
12704112, it ain't all like that though
Posted by Calico, Wed Jan-21-15 11:27 AM
..but i hear u...i watched Hannibal do a small set on Comedy Central one night and the next night i saw him on Comic View...it's was like two totally different people performed....i forget that comedians feel the need to "black it up" sometimes
12704113, White people drink their coffee like this, BUT BLACK PEOPLE...
Posted by Atillah Moor, Wed Jan-21-15 11:27 AM
I think we just call those folks hacks. They're everywhere.
12704115, amateur stand up comedy is the worst.
Posted by John Forte, Wed Jan-21-15 11:27 AM
White amateurs are bad because they're unfunny. Black amateurs are bad because they're unfunny. They're just unfunny in different ways. The overly black shit probably just touches a nerve with you because it's familiar and you recognize the laziness and hackery.
12704125, ^^^^
Posted by bonitaapplebaum71481, Wed Jan-21-15 11:32 AM
base


"i wanna hug all u idiotic bastards & then set you all on fire" -Bin

www.twitter.com/bedstuybetty
http://bedstuybetty.tumblr.com/
DROkayplayer: Giving you good puff since May '05
12704148, this is it
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 11:44 AM
The overly black shit probably just touches
>a nerve you because it's familiar and you recognize the
>laziness and hackery.

I only specified race because it was black night and I never go see live comedy
12704153, *cough* bullshit *cough*
Posted by Deadzombie, Wed Jan-21-15 11:46 AM
>I only specified race because it was black night and I never go see live comedy

you specified black because you want the world to know that you disapprove of being black.

dude. it's okay.

we get it:

i hate black people who talk in public
i hate black people who are early in their career and make jokes on stage
i hate black people who ...

carry on.
12704204, you're a heckler, I get it
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 12:14 PM
only you're online doing it so you lack social skills and friends in general

it's old and not even interesting. OKP was way uglier before you started trolling, we all grew up though
12704284, my disagreeance does not equal heckling.
Posted by Deadzombie, Wed Jan-21-15 12:59 PM
and what does the historical ugliness of OKP have to do with anything?

dont give me no lessons about OKP, i was here.

and i still can't understand why you think it's okay to wish death on someone.

remember when that DJ teddy bear killed himself? didn't you learn how important it is to cherish life and shit, above all?

and you bring this death shit to me?

what the fuck man?
12704216, the end.
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Wed Jan-21-15 12:25 PM
12704117, I spent alot of time in dreadful ameatur comedy club sets.
Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Wed Jan-21-15 11:29 AM
Painful indeed.


**********
"Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson

http://blackpeopleonlocalnews.tumblr.com/
12704129, Why?
Posted by Case_One, Wed Jan-21-15 11:34 AM

.
.
.
"Today is your day to have a better life -- it's your right."
12704160, black comedic subject matter is lacking in general i think
Posted by southphillyman, Wed Jan-21-15 11:50 AM
amateur or not
12704177, let me tell you why: black people love to laugh
Posted by John Forte, Wed Jan-21-15 11:57 AM
it's a part of our culture. We're gregarious, and when we go to comedy shows we want to laugh and we do. There is no better audience for a comedian (or magician) than a room full of black folk.

If you're a comedian, and you're consistently killing, why would you change your material?
12704210, We also don't support each other enough when we step outside our "box"
Posted by micMajestic, Wed Jan-21-15 12:17 PM
>it's a part of our culture. We're gregarious, and when we go
>to comedy shows we want to laugh and we do. There is no better
>audience for a comedian (or magician) than a room full of
>black folk.
>
>If you're a comedian, and you're consistently killing, why
>would you change your material?

And that goes for any form of entertainment created by Black people.


4 Better or 4 Worse
12704211, You're right
Posted by Khalil19, Wed Jan-21-15 12:19 PM
I do comedy in my area and that's the main thing I struggle with. Most (not all) of the Black comics have the same tired ass material and it makes me sick just waiting for my turn to perform. The crowd has a lot to do with the subject matter and style.
Here's the run down of what I see

1. DJ plays some top 40 song and the comic plays on that for the first 2-3 minutes.
2. Black People/White People shit
3. Where my Church People?
4. Remember when you got your ass whipped?

I'm being very general but there's not much deviation from those subjects. It's very frustrating when you're actually attempting to perform something original. I do well in most environments but I don't like performing in front of an all black crowd. I prefer a mixed crowd because I talk to more than just black folk.



















You don't impress me!!




RIP Reggie...I love you!! http://i1206.photobucket.com/albums/bb449/Mynewstuff2011/RegLover.jpg



http://penilegenius.tumblr.com/
12704221, links?
Posted by GHNO, Wed Jan-21-15 12:28 PM
12704235, RE: links?
Posted by Khalil19, Wed Jan-21-15 12:39 PM
Here's an example. We've performed in the same venues a few times! I'm at work so I don't have time to find the comics who really get on my nerves.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-blePZ18UQM





















You don't impress me!!




RIP Reggie...I love you!! http://i1206.photobucket.com/albums/bb449/Mynewstuff2011/RegLover.jpg



http://penilegenius.tumblr.com/
12704551, noooo....I mean links of YOUR routine...
Posted by GHNO, Wed Jan-21-15 03:22 PM
12704801, Only my first show was recorded...
Posted by Khalil19, Wed Jan-21-15 05:20 PM
That was back in August of last year...I start in the 39th minute. None of that material is in my current act though!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EyejoqTJ7Zo










You don't impress me!!




RIP Reggie...I love you!! http://i1206.photobucket.com/albums/bb449/Mynewstuff2011/RegLover.jpg



http://penilegenius.tumblr.com/
12704808, this is interesting.
Posted by Deadzombie, Wed Jan-21-15 05:24 PM
not nearly as bad as i was expecting.

good job.
12704814, That made me laugh...
Posted by Khalil19, Wed Jan-21-15 05:26 PM
The worse part for me is that I didn't have the microphone close enough to my mouth. I'm still a work in progress but THANKS!








You don't impress me!!




RIP Reggie...I love you!! http://i1206.photobucket.com/albums/bb449/Mynewstuff2011/RegLover.jpg



http://penilegenius.tumblr.com/
12704224, depends
Posted by teefiveten, Wed Jan-21-15 12:35 PM
i thought the same thing about amateur comedy in general before i started doing knitting factory but every one of those comedians on the bill are good, even though some aren't great. they clearly had talent

and there are some good shows in nyc that are free/cheap with those same comedians so i like to suggest people go to those shows

but sometimes funny folks get booked on shitty bills and you have to deal with the wackness but discounting it overall isn't the move if you're into comedy
12704230, is there a vetting process for Hannibal's night?
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 12:38 PM
I feel like they let anyone go on stage last night
12704258, i dunno how it works w/ comedians but
Posted by teefiveten, Wed Jan-21-15 12:50 PM
a friend and i remarked how it's similar to DJing

you end up on bills w/ folks or go check out other folks and you connect and support each other and put each other on bills if/when you can and work on other shit if that's what you do (like comedy writing)

at least that's what it looks like to me. it's very much how it is w/ DJing. i don't think it's vetted more than it's just that folks kinda come up together and you help those who help you that you feel that you're on par with. cream rises to the top. some open mic type nights aren't that good but that's part of the process.

those comedians definitely know each other as far as the KF shows go. they chill together in some capacity and build offstage/off showtime. they also drink a lot. lol.
12704262, this is how it works for my comic friend
Posted by John Forte, Wed Jan-21-15 12:51 PM
12704298, yeah that's what it looks like
Posted by teefiveten, Wed Jan-21-15 01:08 PM
knitting factory is/was on a sunday so i usually just do the show and cab it home b/c a sista gotta work in the AM

one time i got to hang back b/c i had a day off and one of comedians remarked that i must have like a boyfriend or a happy life to be out so fast after every show. lol. i would love to chill b/c i know how that works in my field but unfortunately i can't phone it in at the job . at least not this new job.
12704267, also, if you went to check who i think you went to check
Posted by teefiveten, Wed Jan-21-15 12:52 PM
she is WAY BETTER THAN ANY ONE ELSE IVE SEEN HER PERFORM ON A BILL WITH

lol. i had to say it in caps. she's gonna be huge.
12704272, .
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 12:54 PM
.
12704280, she did NY a month or so ago
Posted by teefiveten, Wed Jan-21-15 12:58 PM
i caught one show she did. the rest were awful but i had never heard of them. yeah she's going to rise. just a matter of time.
12704289, !!!
Posted by atruhead, Wed Jan-21-15 01:01 PM
good to know the homie is out here
12704563, y'all not gonna say who it is so we can support?!
Posted by SHAstayhighalways, Wed Jan-21-15 03:29 PM
12704612, word, we some supporting ass mfs round here
Posted by BabySoulRebel, Wed Jan-21-15 03:49 PM
12706127, :)
Posted by teefiveten, Thu Jan-22-15 03:40 PM
http://www.chanelali.com/

next time she's in NY i'll let y'all know
12706146, cool. I saw her at a Helium open mic. She did really well.
Posted by shamus, Thu Jan-22-15 03:46 PM
12706528, that caesar milan bit was mad funny lol
Posted by SHAstayhighalways, Thu Jan-22-15 07:28 PM
i fux with her. good looks!
12706120, Zainab?
Posted by Cam, Thu Jan-22-15 03:37 PM
12704346, if you was at the comedy store you shoulda went to roast battle
Posted by now or never, Wed Jan-21-15 01:34 PM
that shit is upstairs in the belly room and it's epic every week.
trippin on Tuesday is cool bc large niggas pop in, but it can be wack too.
depends on who's in town

-----
No one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public. (c) HL Mencken or some other motherfucker.
12704629, Roast Battle is the best shit in town right now.
Posted by Ryan M, Wed Jan-21-15 03:55 PM
12706523, it's ridiculous.
Posted by now or never, Thu Jan-22-15 07:22 PM
they tryna take it to tv
but it's hard to get a good deal with a network that won't try to change everything and make Brandon T Jackson the host.

-----
No one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public. (c) HL Mencken or some other motherfucker.
12706625, eh. I shouldn't say that.
Posted by Ryan M, Thu Jan-22-15 09:15 PM
Inbox.
12704623, As a dude who sees live comedy 2-4x a week...
Posted by Ryan M, Wed Jan-21-15 03:54 PM
Most amateur comedy is the worst.

Open mics, bringer shows, whatever. They're bad. It's also how comics become GOOD - having to do shows like that. If you can come out of that and develop an act, you're going to be okay.

Now with a lot of that said - many shows that target a certain demographic of comics (IE black night, Latino night, women, gay, whatever) aren't great either. Rather than producing a show with great comics, they're targeting comics based on race/sex/orientation and not content.
12704628, Nahh, you ain't seen enough AMATEUR White comedy. I used to do a spot
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Wed Jan-21-15 03:55 PM
where they had White comedians go before our show, the Improv actually...and even did the same at The Mint. And man....it was where the whole audience would laugh each time, and I just felt like it was an inside joke that I wasn't even supposed to understand.

Like, it would really be shit like.....White dude comes out with a glass of water, and says "hey audience! *they respond* This water is good.....the best tap water L.A. has to offer!! *crowd laughs*....I should just put a mint leaf in it, and call it a Tap-Jito!!! *crowd laughs haaaard* Yeah...just bottle up water from Downtown bathroom sinks and package it up, and call it....Tappp, Heeeeeee-to!!!!! *crowd laughs, then claps...then 10 seconds of silence til the next joke*

12706536, LOL, how come I can actually hear in my head....
Posted by The Wordsmith, Thu Jan-22-15 07:35 PM
...some bland White comedian telling that joke? I've seen White comics telling corny jokes of that nature where they'd get major laughs and I would wonder what the hell was everyone laughing at. I try to think that the crowd is drunk and/or high.


Since 1976
12706764, Man, I actually don't know if I made that shit up, or if I really heard it!
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Fri Jan-23-15 05:11 AM
That's really the type shit they'll say to get MAJOR laughs off of!
12706765, Man, I actually don't know if I made that shit up, or if I really heard it!
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Fri Jan-23-15 05:11 AM
That's really the type shit they'll say to get MAJOR laughs off of!
12704807, That's why I hate "black" Vine
Posted by PimpTrickGangstaClik, Wed Jan-21-15 05:24 PM
Very little creativity. Pretty much all the jokes are about Jordans or some racial stereotype
12704821, is amateur stand-up worse than amateur spoken word?
Posted by woe.is.me., Wed Jan-21-15 05:29 PM
12704852, i barely even like non-amatuer spoken word
Posted by SHAstayhighalways, Wed Jan-21-15 05:48 PM
but you didn't even ask all that. i just had to let that out tho
lol
12704869, lol
Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Jan-21-15 05:59 PM
12704870, brrrrrap braaaap!
Posted by woe.is.me., Wed Jan-21-15 06:01 PM
lol
12706140, LOL
Posted by teefiveten, Thu Jan-22-15 03:45 PM
.
12706135, amateur stand up in general is bad.
Posted by PROMO, Thu Jan-22-15 03:44 PM
being funny is not easy.

getting people to relate to you is harder.

taking all that AND being somewhat, if not completely original, is the hardest.

i don't think it's a black or white thing. it's probably just more noticeable because there are fewer black people doing standup. if you went to an all-white night you'd think the same.
12706265, Women Be SHOPPING!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by TR808, Thu Jan-22-15 04:25 PM
WOMEN BE SHOPPEEEENNNNNG
12706767, That shit was hilarious back then, and it still is (c) Guru
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Fri Jan-23-15 05:53 AM