Go back to previous topic
Forum namePass The Popcorn Archives
Topic subjectRE: You really didn't read what he wrote.
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=23&topic_id=107141&mesg_id=107257
107257, RE: You really didn't read what he wrote.
Posted by Sleepy, Wed Jan-02-13 03:54 PM
>>in short, this is the first film i've seen
>>>that accurately portrays the confederate south as-- in a
>>>history littered with slavery and genocide-- quite possibly
>>>the most morally corrupt society that has ever existed.
>>
>>I totally disagree with this statement. There's no way
>>possible you think this is the most accurate account of
>>slavery on film. That doesn't even make sense. There's 2
>>beatings, and one account of torture, and a murder (which
>>wasn't even done by human hands). None of the other
>>unmentionable dastardly deeds are shown.
>
>
>Read that sentence again. He didn't say it was the most
>accurate account of slavery on film. Like, that's not even
>close to what he said.

You know you're right. I misread that statement. I still disagree about it though. I didn't get a feeling for the confederate south at all after seeing it. It seemed more like the focus on slavery and those involved than the people around it. But I understand his point that everyone was implicit and deserved retribution.