Go back to previous topic | Forum name | Pass The Popcorn Archives | Topic subject | **BACKFLIPS INTO POST**(i.e. Bags is right, again) | Topic URL | http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=23&topic_id=45340&mesg_id=45397 |
45397, **BACKFLIPS INTO POST**(i.e. Bags is right, again) Posted by Orbit_Established, Mon Jan-29-07 08:09 AM
You guys, again, aren't using your noodles.
Bags is right, but he shoulda just used a different metric:
If you take it in terms of total number of famous alum, SNL wins(though not by much, because SNL puts out a pathetically large number of insignificant, unfunny actors/comedians).
If you, however, use the metric:
mean fame/alumni(the average fame secured per alumni)
ILC wins by far.
Not even close.
And trust, the latter metric is actually the more fair one, because it controls for the fact that SNL has much larger casts, and has a quarter century head start. '
ALSO, ILC was on FOX in the early days of the network and was, at best(in terms of ratings) a cult hit.
SNL, on the other hand, is the single most mainstream sketch comedy show in the history of television. Its owned Saturday night for decades just off culture alone(meaning, it didn't even need to be funny. I watched it for years and barely laughed. It was just reflex, though, to turn it on if I was home on Sat night).
That being the case, ORDERS OF MAGNITUDE MORE PEOPLE were exposed to SNLs actors and actresses over the years. The fact that SNL, with a quarter century head start and far more viewers, still comes up short in avg fame/alumni is a testament to ILCs brilliance, and SNLs mediocrity.
ALSO, to the issue of Jaime Foxx and Jim Carrey:
Regaredless of whether or not Foxx got his Oscar for being funny or not, ILC introduced more TALENTED PEOPLE to the world than SNL did, again, by the avg fame/alumni unit. Both Foxx and Carrey's non comedic brilliance is tied to their comedic talent -- both were physical comedians who could mold into different characters, take on different personas. Its no coincidence that these two ended up excellent character actors.
And no doubt about it -- both got acting gigs AT ALL because of their COMEDIC TALENTS FIRST, which then LED TO OTHER GIGS. That being the case, ILC has EVERY RIGHT to claim both Carrey and Foxx's success. ILC introduced the world to both.
So, again, Bags made the mistake of thinking ahead of you guys.
You are too mad, too artsy, too anal retentive, too haterish, and most importantly, not intelligent enough to sort through this issue fairly because, obviously, when you think about it at all, Bags has a point. I mean, you can disagree, but you guys are doing it in flippant fashion which is unwarranted.
Mang.
----------------------------
O_E: Your Super-Ego's Favorite Poster.
"I ORBITs the solar system, listenin..."
(C)Keith Murray, "Cosmic Slop
| |