Go back to previous topic
Forum nameOkay Sports Archives
Topic subjectthe word out of Green Bay was he's done as a cold weather QB
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=21&topic_id=66263&mesg_id=66443
66443, the word out of Green Bay was he's done as a cold weather QB
Posted by natlawdp, Wed Aug-19-09 12:38 PM
>>
>>i don't think he'll be better than Sage outdoors this winter.
>
>>
>Based on what? Sage had twice as many turnovers as TDs last
>year, never started more than five games in a season and has
>never gone into a season as a starter heading into his now
>ninth year in the league and fifth team.

factor in age and health, and i think his recent history points toward a late season drop-off in production

>>>>i refuse to believe that the Ghost of Brett Favre Past
>will
>>>>cast a fearsome shadow over the Norris for a full season,
>>>let
>>>>alone playoffs. if anything, cats are gonna line up to
>>>drill
>>>>this bama like they did Jordan on his last go at it.
>>>>
>>>That's different from '07 or '08 how?
>>>
>>
>>'07 was actually Favre, the Green Bay HOF'er
>>'08 foreshadows what's going down in '09, 'cept this time
>its
>>in the division the Ghost of Favre played in...
>>
>You were speaking to cats lining up to drill him, the point is
>that's been the case all along except when he was doing Mike
>Strahan a favor.
>

Vikes at Chicago and Green Bay were already notable games- adding Favre certainly pumps up AT LEAST the atmosphere for those games, just like he did in the AFC during '08; 'cept this time its against players he was either torching for YEARS or a staff that knows him pretty well.

>>>Jeff Garcia is done.
>>
>>you might be right. favre might be done too- he's said it
>>himself, and the team went out of their way to beg him to
>test
>>it NOT in training camp, but on the 2009 season. helluva
>>gamble- should've rolled the dice on Cutler if they truly
>>believed their QBs suck that badly...
>
>I'll roll with Favre in a system he spent 16 years in over
>Jeff Garcia playing on his fifth team in six years when he
>couldn't get over the 50 versus the Raiders with a chance to
>go to the playoffs on the line.
>
>And 'rolling the dice' on Favre as a free-agent for a season
>doesn't mortgage your future with multiple first-rounders like
>a Cutler trade would have.

Cutler is too much of a gamble in terms of cost, and Sage is too much of a gamble in terms of talent, so the solution is Favre for one year coming off injury and skipping training camp? i guess it truly boils down to me being skeptical of his ability to hold up, thus reducing his talent level advantage. and i do think it's going to take at least a month for him to get in sync with his receivers. and finally, management is either forcing this on childress or their all lunchin'.