I don't have huge hands but I have long fingers so whenever I played older PS generations I'd always cramp after a few hours of playing. Making it bigger has been a huge plus and I'm a big fan of the center touch button.

That said, asymmetrical sticks, the better triggers and (for me) better shape are why I still prefer the X1 controller. It's definitely close though and I have no (real) complaints about the DS4.

My main gripe with it honestly is that since my PS4 is in the bedroom, I often put the controller on the bed, causing inadvertent trigger presses. I don't like how it doesn't have a guard for the triggers but that's extremely minor.