But I don't see it. Yeah not many weapons but they all have dramatically different moves. I have been using Ludwig's and I am still finding new moves.

Then there are chalice dungeons which can be randomized and get tougher and tougher.

Covenants aren't as robust but let's be serious: most of the covenants in dark souls were useless.

Whenever I beat a boss, I go back and read about it, and it's amazing all the different items and strategies for each boss.

I think the game will have plenty of replay. People seem to be zealous about the Souls games so people decry anything that isnt the first one.