276254, Aren't all individual feature wars moot? Android wins every time Posted by Wonderl33t, Mon Oct-01-12 02:03 PM
The phone as a whole is different story, but rehashing iPhone vs the World on individual features is not even a contest.
>http://online.wsj.com/article_email/SB10001424052702304543904577398502695522974-lMyQjAxMTAyMDAwNDEwNDQyWj.html > >Since they got together in 2007, the iPhone and Google Maps >have seemed like ideal digital bedfellows. > >Google Inc.'s GOOG -1.81% blockbuster map service—which allows >web users to find businesses, check traffic conditions and get >directions—has helped Apple Inc.'s AAPL -0.68% iPhone become >wildly successful. Surging iPhone use has, in turn, driven >tons of web traffic to Google's search engine through Google >Maps. > >But not for long. Mobile map technology is about to become the >latest battleground in the two tech giants' escalating war >over who dominates the future of computing. > >Later this year, Apple is planning to oust Google Maps as the >preloaded, default maps app from the iPhone and iPad and >release a new mapping app that runs Apple's own technology, >according to current and former Apple employees. Apple could >preview the new software, which will be part of its next >mobile-operating system, as soon as next week at its annual >developer conference in San Francisco, one person familiar >with the plans says. Apple plans to encourage app developers >to embed its maps inside their applications like >social-networking and search services. Technology blog 9to5Mac >earlier reported that Apple will launch its own maps app in >its next mobile-operating system. > >Apple has been hatching the plan to evict Google Maps from the >iPhone for years, according to current and former Apple >employees. The plan accelerated as smartphones powered by >Google's Android software overtook the iPhone in shipments. > > >It's Apple versus Google in a battle of the maps as Apple is >expected to unveil its new map app. WSJ's Jessica Vascellaro >has the details. > >Apple has quietly acquired at least three cutting-edge map >companies, melding their technology with its own. Last fall, >Apple took a first step in developing a proprietary mapping >service with the virtually unnoticed release of a >"geocoder"—the brains behind a mapping app that translates a >phone's longitude and latitude into a point on a map, like an >address. Before that, it relied on Google's geocoder. > >Mobile ads associated with maps or locations are estimated to >account for about 25% of the roughly $2.5 billion spent on >mobile ads in 2012, according to Opus Research, up from 10% in >2010. That is expected to grow as the number of location-aware >software apps grows. > >But more than ad revenue, Apple is going after the map market >to have more control over a key asset in the widening >smartphone war. Google Maps is used by more than 90% of U.S. >iPhone users. So Apple believes controlling the mapping >experience and offering features that Google doesn't have can >help sell more devices and entice developers to build unique >apps for iPhone users. > > >In the short term, Google will lose some ad revenue and miss >out on data about what local businesses people are searching >for—which it uses to pitch retailers on buying certain ads. >Longer term, it is likely to hurt Google's ability to generate >map-related revenue, according to former Google employees. > >A Google spokeswoman said it would be premature to comment on >something that hasn't happened. > >Apple's turnabout on Google goes well beyond maps. How the war >plays out will help shape how people use technology for years >to come. > >"Apple is aiming squarely at Google on multiple dimensions," >says Rajeev Chand, a managing director at investment bank >Rutberg & Co., citing mapping and Web search. "Google and >Apple are in a battle over data, devices, services, and the >future of computing. This is the historic battle of today." > >For years, Apple and Google were models of cooperation. Each >largely stuck to its separate world—Apple made computers and >other hardware; Google offered Web search and sold online ads. >Apple's longtime chief, Steve Jobs, had close relations with >Google chief Eric Schmidt, who sat on Apple's board of >directors from 2006 until 2009. > >The rise of the iPhone and other smartphones changed all that. >Mr. Jobs felt blindsided by Google's push into mobile devices >with its own Android operating system. Google has since >entered the hardware business directly, buying Motorola >Mobility Holdings, which makes phones. Google recently also >launched a music, movie, book and mobile-app store to compete >with Apple's iTunes. Android-phone shipments now surpass >iPhone shipments globally. > >Some Google executives privately say they think Apple is >trying to wean iPhone users away from using traditional Web >search on its phones. > >The use of Google search on the iPhone is believed by several >mobile industry analysts to generate the majority of Google's >mobile search-ad revenue. Google has accelerated its plans to >develop its own voice-activated search assistant for >Android-powered mobile devices, which is expected to launch >later this year, these people said. > >Apple's goal is to develop a "holistic" technology that >integrates maps with other Apple software, says a person >briefed on the strategy. For instance, if Apple's iCalendar >program knows that a person has a meeting across town soon, >and traffic is backing up, it might alert the person about >road conditions. > >Originally, Apple's iPhone strengthened ties between the two >companies. On Halloween in 2006just months before the iPhone >was announced—Apple's product-marketing head, Phil Schiller, >and other executives met with Google engineers to determine >how the iPhone could use Google's mapping data to let people >see their locations and get directions. At the meeting, one >Google employee attended wearing a nun costume. > >The two companies struck a quid pro quo: When an iPhone user >opened the mapping app, Apple would send Google information >about the position of a particular phone. Google would then >return mapping images and other data. The January 2007 iPhone >news release called Google's mapping service >"groundbreaking." > >Google's release of Android, the rival smartphone operating >system, started souring things. In 2008, Mr. Jobs warned >Google co-founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin that if they >continued with Android, Apple would head to court and claim >Android copied the iPhone. Google proceeded, and Apple sued a >slew of Android-device manufacturers. The cases are still >making their way through the courts. > >Maps added to the rancor. That same year, Apple executives >including Mr. Schiller sat down with Google executives, >including Vic Gundotra, then a vice president in charge of >Google's mobile apps, to renew the agreement over the iPhone's >mapping app. > >New tensions emerged when Apple grew concerned that Google was >aggressively gathering data from the app, according to people >familiar with Apple's thinking. Mr. Schiller worried it could >compromise users' privacy, these people said. > >Google executives felt Apple was unreasonable in insisting on >controlling the look of the maps app and enabling only some of >its features—like an "a la carte menu" where Google provided >only the "back end" technology that powers it, according to a >Google executive. > >The two sides bickered over a Google Maps feature called >Street View, which lets people see an actual photo as if they >are standing in the street. Apple wanted to incorporate Street >View on the iPhone just as Google already offered it for >Android phones. Google initially withheld the feature, >frustrating Apple executives, according to people on both >sides of the debate. > >Apple executives also wanted to include Google's >turn-by-turn-navigation service in the iPhone—a feature >popular with Android users because it lets people treat their >phones as in-car GPS devices. Google wouldn't allow it, >according to people on both sides. One of these people said >Google viewed Apple's terms as unfair. > >Google executives, meantime, also bristled at Apple's refusal >to add features that would help Google. For instance, Google >wanted to emphasize its brand name more prominently within the >maps app. It also wanted Apple to enable its service designed >to find friends nearby, dubbed Latitude, which Apple refrained >from doing, said people on both sides. > >Relations between Messrs. Schiller and Gundotra got tense. >Jeff Huber, then a Google vice president of engineering, >eventually started handling talks with Apple as Mr. Gundotra >moved on to a new project within Google, people familiar with >the matter said. > >In 2009, Mr. Schmidt confided in colleagues his concern over >the fraying relationship, one of these people said. Around >that same time, Mr. Jobs decided that location services were >too important for Apple to rely on a partner that was also >becoming a formidable competitor, says a person familiar with >the matter. > >So Mr. Jobs began looking outside Apple for talent to build >its own mapping technology. In 2009, Apple bought a small Los >Angeles company, Placebase, that was trying to build a service >like Google Maps. When the Placebase team arrived in Apple >headquarters in Cupertino, they formed Apple's new "geo >team"—and initially sat across the hall from Mr. Jobs. > >In August 2009, Mr. Schmidt quit the Apple board, with Mr. >Jobs citing the growing competition in a news release. The >relationship deteriorated further when Apple decided to enter >the lucrative business of selling mobile advertising—until >then, a business dominated by Google and smaller mobile ad >firms. Mr. Jobs courted a mobile-ad service, AdMob, but Google >snatched the company for $750 million in November 2009. > >In January 2010, Apple bought an AdMob rival, Quattro >Wireless. The fight left Mr. Jobs more eager to sever ties. >Shortly after the acquisition, he told Apple employees in an >all-hands meeting, that Google's behavior suggested that its >"Don't be evil" corporate motto was "bull—," according to >former Apple employees. The comment was understood to imply >that Google had betrayed its relationship with Apple by >entering its turf. > >Google executives, including CEO Mr. Page, have publicly said >that Google began work on Android in 2005, before it knew of >Apple's plans for the iPhone. > >When Apple in 2010 bought Poly9, a maker of zoomable 3-D maps, >it raised alarms at Google, says a person familiar with >Google's reaction, which took it as a sign that Apple was >serious about building its own service. Poly9, a small company >based in Quebec, had built technology similar to Google's own >satellite mapping service, Google Earth, which allows users to >browse around a three-dimensional globe. > >Meanwhile, Apple's geo team worked on features that might be >able to one-up Google. Apple kept the details secret, even >in-house. When one member of the geo team asked another what >he was working on, he did little more than shrug, says one >person familiar with the matter. > >Apple had catching up to do. Employees worked on mapping >designs to sub out Google's from the iPhone. They began work >on a navigation app that resembles an in-car GPS device, says >a person familiar with the project. > >Apple also began licensing data about road-traffic conditions >and local businesses from around the world. Apple needed more >data for a critical step: building its new "geocoder," the >code that translates longitudes and latitudes into actual >addresses. > >Apple wasn't pleased with Google's geocoding in part because >Google's geocoder wouldn't let Apple use it unless Apple also >showed a Google map every time it did so. > >So Apple engineers worked on building their own geocoder. In a >sign of the geo team's growing importance, Apple moved it into >the esteemed iOS software unit, which is run by Scott >Forstall, who oversees many of Apple's top priority projects. > >Apple quietly launched its geocoder last fall inside its >latest iPhone software. It has remained all but unnoticed >outside a small circle of software pros. > >Since Apple released its own geocoder, every time iPhone users >open its map app, it is Apple's technology that translates >their position, not Google's. Software developers can also use >a version of the Apple technology, CLGeocoder, to build apps >that let users, for instance, tell their friends what >neighborhood they are in or search for nearby eateries. > >With Mr. Page now running Google and Tim Cook at Apple's helm, >the companies aren't bickering much in public. But the rivalry >is heating up. > >Members of the Google Maps team in recent months have told >colleagues they worry about Apple replacing their program, >given that as many as half the people who access Google Maps >own Apple devices, says someone familiar with the matter. > >The Google Maps team takes solace in the growth in Android >devices, which preload Google Maps. > >Knowing that Apple might reveal its new mapping software the >week of June 11, Google scheduled a news conference for June >6. The purpose: to unveil "the next dimension of Google >Maps."
<--- Blind faith
|